Small Business Administration
The Payment Integrity Information Act of 2019 (PIIA) was established to improve efforts to identify and reduce Government-wide improper payments. PIIA requires agencies to estimate improper payments and report on actions to reduce improper payments. In accordance with Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Circular A-123, Appendix C, Requirements for Payment Integrity Improvement (M-21-19) (hereafter referred to as “Appendix C”), agencies are required to identify, assess, prioritize, and respond to payment integrity risks to prevent improper payments in the most appropriate manner. This report will discuss the SBA’s efforts and results related to improper payment assessment and reviews. More detailed information on improper payments and information previously reported in the AFR that is not included in the FY 2026 AFR can be found on PaymentAccuracy.gov.
The SBA’s improper payment reviews are a multi-layered process that starts with a risk assessment. If a risk assessment indicates that a program is susceptible to improper payments, then testing is performed using a statistically valid sampling technique. Based upon the testing results, a corrective action plan is developed to prevent and remediate the types of errors uncovered. If testing finds a significant amount of recoverable dollars, the SBA considers the appropriateness of performing a recovery audit.
The detection and remediation of improper payments is a priority for the Agency. SBA staff monitor and review for improper payments and implement improvements that will reduce improper payment rates. The SBA also continually seeks opportunities to enhance and implement internal controls to reduce the risk of improper payments.
For FY 2025 the Agency was found to be non-compliant with PIIA due to improper and unknown payment rates exceeding the 10% threshold in certain programs, inaccurate reporting, incomplete risk assessments, inadequately supported payment estimates and corrective-action plans, missed reduction targets, and failure to submit required information.
To begin with remedying the issues identified by the auditors, SBA has instituted Corrective Action Plans (CAP's). These plans are designed to address the findings above and bring the Agency into compliance with PIIA. SBA anticipates achieving compliance for the audit of FY2027 activities.
The SBA conducts risk assessments on a three-year rotation cycle for programs not deemed susceptible to significant improper payments, or earlier if a program was subjected to significant change in legislation or funding level. Monitoring of off-cycle activity is also performed and responded to when significant changes occur. The qualitative risk assessment applies an individual risk weight to each risk factor to account for the variability in potential risk that each risk factor could impose on a program. In FY 2026, the agency completed one risk assessment over travel expenditures. The program was found to be not susceptible to improper payments.
For FY 2026, the SBA had 6 programs reporting Phase II improper payment estimates: 504 Certified Development Companies (CDC) Loan Approvals; 7(a) Loan Guarantee Approvals; 7(a) Loan Guarantee Purchases; Disaster Assistance Loans; Paycheck Protection Plan (PPP) Loan Forgiveness; and PPP Loan Purchases.
The statistical approach remained consistent between FY 2025 and FY 2026 for all the programs, with the exception for 504 Certified Development Companies (CDC) Loan Approvals that began daily sample selection (instead of monthly) for the remaining 3 months of the PIIA period.
1. 504 CDC Loan Approvals
For FY 2026 504 Approvals, the Improper plus unknown rate was calculated at 2.69%, for a total estimated amount of $203.77 million. Compared to the prior reporting period, this was a reduction in both percentage and dollars, down from 4.58% and $338.42 million in FY 2025.
The primary causes of improper payments included: CDCs’ failure to perform due diligence on borrowers and collateral and CDCs’ failure to adequately address job creation requirements.
The reduction can be accredited to the Agency’s continuous quarterly lender training and quality reviews by the Sacramento Loan Processing Center (SLPC), as most loans selected for the PIIA reviews were submitted under lenders’ non-delegated authority.
To reduce future improper payments, a Corrective Action Plan has been formalized. Specific corrective actions are determined based upon the primary reason for the improper payment with the purpose of both remedying the improper payment and preventing recurrence.
Plans for improvement include the following: collaborating with the Office of Credit Risk Management (OCRM) to recommend that specific lender deficiencies be monitored and incorporated into Risk-Based Reviews; collaborating with the Office of Financial Assistance (OFA) to inform the office of deficiencies identified for potential incorporation into policy, regulatory, or standard operating procedure rewrite or update; and conducting external training for lenders to ensure that appropriate documentation is obtained and analyzed prior to loan approval that policy requirements are met.
SBA has made multiple updates to PIIA review notification and procedures related to 504 loan approvals. Per SOP 50 10 8 effective 6/1/25, CDCs are responsible for ensuring there is no open PIIA review before a 504 loan moves forward to closing. 504 loan approval samples are pulled multiple times per week shortly after loan commitment and CDCs along with Third Party Lenders (TPL) are notified promptly of selection. All results are shared with both CDCs and TPLs. There are also internal checks in place to ensure no 504 loan with an open PIIA review moves toward closing.
2. 7(a) Loan Guaranty Approvals
For FY 2026 7(a) Approvals, the improper payment rate was calculated at 8.31%, for an estimated amount of $1985.9 million. Compared to the prior reporting period, this is an increase from 6.13% ($1632.51 million) in FY 2025.
The primary causes of improper payments included lenders’ failure to verify all components of loan eligibility (program integrity or project structure issues), failure to provide required loan documentation, and data entry errors.
This increase is attributed to unintentional lender underwriting errors and insufficient documentation under delegated processing. To address this, the program implemented updated SOP requirements effective June 2025, reinstituted the SBA Franchise Directory with streamlined procedures, restored underwriting criteria, and delivered pre- and post-issuance quarterly training.
The Agency further plans to refer lender deficiencies to OCRM for Risk-Based Reviews, collaborate with the Loan Guarantee Processing Center (LGPC) and the Office of Financial Assistance (OFA) on policy updates, and deliver external training to lenders on eligibility, structure, and documentation in FY 2027 to achieve its target reduction rate.
3. 7(a) Loan Guaranty Purchases
For FY 2026 7(a) Purchases, the improper payment rate was calculated at 1.52%, for an estimated amount of $40.3 million. Compared to the prior reporting period, this was a slight increase from an improper rate of 1.07% and an unknown rate of 0.44% with a total estimated rate of 1.51% ($31.86 million) in FY 2025. Identified deficiencies included lender underwriting errors and insufficient documentation.
The primary causes of improper payments included discrepancies in Secondary Market Reconciliation, Debt Refinance Eligibility, Transcripts of Accounts, Care and Preservation of Collateral Expenses and Equity Injection Documentation missing.
The program addressed payment integrity by issuing an updated 7(a) Loan Servicing and Liquidation SOP (effective November 2025) and providing pre-issuance and quarterly training to lenders and internal staff.
The Agency further plans to evaluate the reinstatement of Secondary Market Reconciliation in purchase procedures, conduct internal training for purchase processors and reviewers on complete loan history verification, and provide loan-level feedback in FY 2027 to maintain its target reduction rate.
4. Disaster Assistance Loans
For FY 2026 Disaster Assistance Loans, the improper payment rate was calculated at 8.04% ($151.36 million). Compared to the prior reporting period, this was an increase from 4.87% ($157.02 million) in FY 2025.
The primary causes of improper payments included fees charged for secured loans contrary to the Code of Federal Regulations (13 CFR 123.8), duplication of benefits not adequately addressed, and improper calculation or determination of economic injury eligibility.
The increase in the improper payment rate from FY 2025 to FY 2026 was largely attributable to improperly assessed loan closing fees, duplication of benefits (DOB) which were not adequately identified or accounted for, and errors in the calculation or determination of economic injury eligibility. The deficiencies affected compliance with fee restrictions, consideration for insurance proceeds and other assistance for the same disaster-related losses, and the determination of borrower eligibility and loan amounts.
To address this, the program instituted a corrective action allowing disaster survivors to close loans independently or authorize SBA to close on their behalf. The Agency further plans to deploy an updated SOP 50 30 and leverage automated processing controls within the Unified Lending Platform (ULP) in FY 2027 to address root causes and achieve its target reduction rate.
5. PPP Loan Forgiveness
For FY 2026 PPP Loan Forgiveness, the improper payment rate was calculated at 20.26% ($19.4 million). Compared to the prior reporting period, this was a slight increase from an improper rate of 19.04% and an unknown rate of 0.17% with a total estimated rate of 19.21% ($58.39 million) in FY 2025. While the improper rate increased slightly, the dollar value decreased significantly, reflecting the winding down of the PPP program.
The primary causes of improper payments included missing or incomplete documentation, as well as borrower and lender calculation errors. The increase in rate was primarily caused by the inability to obtain supporting documentation from borrowers/lenders for historical 2019–2021 records due to the passage of time.
The Agency plans to execute a quality control review process, internally escalate complex loan reviews, and refer false certifications to the SBA OIG in FY 2027 to work toward its 10.0% statutory reduction target.
6. PPP Loan Guaranty Purchases
For FY 2026 PPP Loan Guaranty Purchases, the improper payment rate was calculated at 1.15% ($23.82 million). Compared to the prior reporting period, this was a significant reduction from an improper payment rate of 5.17% and an unknown payment rate of 8.11% with a total estimated rate of 13.28% ($185.74 million) in FY 2025.
The primary causes of improper payments included lenders’ failure to verify that the borrower was in business on February 20, 2020, failure to verify average monthly payroll, and unacceptable or missing borrower identification.
This reduction represents a major improvement in payment integrity, bringing the program into full compliance with PIIA and meeting its reduction target. The Agency further plans to demand repayment of improper guaranty funds from lenders and refer complex cases to the Guaranty Review Team in FY 2027.
Agency level Payment Integrity results
-
Payment accuracy rate
(Based on federal funding spent by programs determined by agencies as susceptible to improper payments)
-
Improper payments rate
(Based on federal funding spent by programs determined by agencies as susceptible to improper payments)
-
Unknown payments rate
(Based on federal funding spent by programs determined by agencies as susceptible to improper payments)
-
Small Business Administration improper payment estimates over time
View as:
Chart toggle amounts:Proper paymentsOverpaymentUnderpaymentTechnically improperUnknown
Recovery information
Please note: Overpayment amounts recovered are reported in the year they were recovered, not the year they were identified. Therefore it is possible in some years to have a recovery rate greater than 100%.
| Overpayment amount identified through recovery activities | $15.37 M |
| Overpayment amount recovered through recovery activities | $0.3 M |
| Recovery activities recovery rate | 1.95 % |
Why recovery audits are not cost effective in certain programs
In prior years, SBA has conducted cost-benefit analysis on programs subject to payment recapture audit and deemed the cost to perform a payment recapture audit outweighed the benefits of the audit. Although payment recovery audits are not conducted, SBA makes every effort to recover any improper payments identified through the improper payment review process or other internal review process.
Intentional monetary loss improper payments are more commonly referred to as financial fraud and are overpayments that occur on purpose. This agency reported $448.83M of confirmed fraud in this reporting cycle.
Supplemental Information
The Small Business Administration (SBA) has integrated Treasury’s Do Not Pay (DNP) Initiative into its payment integrity and pre-award screening workflows. Programmatic loan disbursements are systematically validated against DNP both pre-award and pre-loan disbursement. For SBA’s grant programs, Grant Solutions Recipient Data Insights, an integrated DNP capability within Grant Solutions, is used.
1. DNP Databases & Verification Sources Used
To ensure comprehensive screening across death records, exclusions, sanctions, and credit risks, the SBA leverages daily API connectivity to query key federal DNP databases, including:
• Department of Defense Death Source (DOD)
• Department of State Death Source (DOS)
• Death Master File (DMF)
• Obituary Death Source (AIS-OBIT)
• Probate Death Source (AIS-PROB)
• System for Award Management (SAM) Entity Registration
• List of Excluded Individuals/Entities (LEIE-PUB) – Screening individuals and entities excluded from participating in Medicare, Medicaid, and other federal healthcare programs.
• Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) – Identifying blocked assets and sanctioned entities/persons prohibited from conducting business with U.S. parties.
• Credit Alert Verification Reporting System (CAIVRS) – Credit alert and delinquent federal debt screening.
• Treasury Offset Program (TOP) – Debt check screening.
2. Frequency of Review & System Automation
Pre-award and pre-disbursement checks are automated via daily API calls integrated directly into agency financial management systems, enabling real-time verification. During Fiscal Year 2026, the SBA executed 2,146,970 DNP API calls to maintain continuous system-to-system verification.
3. Scope of FY 2026 Payments Reviewed
During Fiscal Year 2026, the SBA reviewed over 17,000 pre-disbursement transactions, totaling more than $1.133 billion in program outlays.
4. Improper Payments Prevented & Corrective Actions
Through rigorous pre-award screening, DNP checks served as an effective front-end control by stopping 7,472 applications from becoming loans during FY 2026.
• Pre-Disbursement Controls: When DNP match anomalies are flagged prior to disbursement, the SBA requires the intended recipient to successfully resolve the finding before becoming eligible for SBA funding.
• Post-Disbursement Remediation: For anomalies identified on disbursements already released, the SBA immediately places a hold code on the loan or grant and/or denies future financial assistance, loan relief, or awards until the recipient fully resolves the DNP finding.
The Working System has reduced/prevented improper payments:
The Working System strives to maintain accurate data. However, the past year, SBA has identified incorrect information in the Working System Daily.
SBA was found non-compliant during the most recent PIIA compliance review.
Non-compliant programs:
- 504 Certified Development Loans Approvals
- 7(a) Loan Guarantees Approvals
- 7(a) Loan Guarantees Purchases
- Disaster Assistance Loans
- Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) Loan Forgiveness
- Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) Loan Guaranty Purchases
Show full list of compliant programs
Compliant programs:
- 7(j) Technical Assistance
- 8(a) Business Development Program
- Community Navigator Pilot Program
- Congressional Grants
- Cybersecurity for Small Business Pilot Program
- Economic Injury Disaster Loan Emergency Advance
- Federal and State Technology Partnership Program
- Growth Accelerator Fund Competition
- HUBZone Program
- Intermediary Loan Program
- Microloan Program
- Native American Outreach
- Ombudsman and Regulatory Fairness Boards
- Prime Technical Assistance
- Regional Innovation Clusters
- SBA Administrative Payroll
- SBA Administrative Travel
- SBA Emerging Leaders initiative
- SBA Other Administrative Spending
- Service Corps of Retired Executives Program (SCORE)
- Shuttered Venue Operators Grant Program
- Small Business Development Center (SBDC)
- Small Business Investment Companies Advances
- Small Business Investment Companies Purchases
- State Trade Expansion Program
- Surety Bond Guarantees (SBG)
- Transition Assistance Entrepreneurship Track (Boots to Business)
- Veterans Outreach Program
- Women's Business Ownership Assistance
Actions recommended and planned to achieve compliance
Criterion 1: Complete & Accurate AFR Disclosures
OIG Findings: AFR disclosures contained numbers that did not match website data (e.g., Section 1112 overpayment breakdowns) or listed wrong fiscal year figures (e.g., Disaster Assistance Loan tolerable rates).
OIG Recommendation: Build a formal review and validation process over the AFR and PaymentAccuracy.gov materials.
Agency Action & Milestones: OCFO concurred and is setting up standardized review procedures, defined staff roles, and better communication protocols to verify all data before publication.
Criterion 2: Program Risk Assessments
OIG Findings: SBA failed to complete and document required annual/three-year risk assessments across all applicable programs in FY 2025.
OIG Recommendation: Formally design and implement a risk assessment process to ensure all programs are evaluated on schedule.
Agency Action & Milestones: OCFO redesigned its risk assessment process to cover all PIIA risk factors and automate tracking for mandatory review frequencies.
Criterion 3: Sampling & Estimation Reliability
OIG Findings: Reviewers skipped testing interest calculations on sampled PPP Loan Guaranty Purchases, making data incomplete, while SVOG/PPP Forgiveness sampling plans had statistical calculation errors.
OIG Recommendation: Expand sample review steps to cover all payment components and increase executive oversight over statistical calculations.
Agency Action & Milestones: OCA expanded sample review procedures to include interest testing, and OCFO standardized statistical extrapolation processes with built-in validation and back-testing controls.
Criterion 4: Corrective Action Plans & Root Causes
OIG Findings: SBA lacked supporting documentation for PPP Purchase corrective action plans and misaligned root cause categories between the AFR and web materials.
OIG Recommendation: Establish formal monitoring controls and an audit trail to prove corrective actions are implemented and tied to true root causes.
Agency Action & Milestones: OCA concurred and is setting up a centralized tracking repository to document corrective action milestones, log evidence, and ensure alignment with root causes.
Criterion 5: Reduction Targets & Rate Improvements
OIG Findings: Error rates increased for 7(a) Approvals, 504 Approvals, and Disaster Loans; reduction targets were missed across five programs; and required quarterly OMB scorecards were omitted for High-Priority programs.
OIG Recommendation: Implement stronger front-end controls to prevent bad payments and establish formal procedures to submit High-Priority scorecards.
Agency Action & Milestones: OCA is tightening pre-approval lender eligibility checks under updated SOPs, while OCFO is coordinating off-cycle scorecard submissions with OMB and establishing a quarterly tracking schedule.
Criterion 6: Error Rates Under 10% & Budget Submissions
OIG Findings: PPP Forgiveness, PPP Purchases, and SVOG exceeded the 10% statutory error threshold, and SBA failed to include required program integrity proposals in its budget request after consecutive years of non-compliance.
OIG Recommendation: Strengthen lender documentation recovery and implement tracking to automatically trigger required budget proposals for repeat non-compliant programs.
Agency Action & Milestones: OCFO created a multi-year non-compliance tracking checklist to ensure statutory budget proposals are submitted, while OCA is enforcing stricter documentation recovery workflows with lenders.
Official(s) accountable for the progress of the agency coming into compliance
Nathan Davis, Chief Financial Officer
Accountability mechanism tied to the success of the official designated in leading the efforts to come Into compliance
Executive performance ratings include a performance level related to review, compliance and audit remediation efforts
The agency made substantial changes to the methodology of the review conducted for risk for improper payments for the reporting cycle.
| Program name | When was the last improper payment risk assessment conducted? | Likely to be susceptible to significant improper payments? | Substantial changes made to the assessment methodology used for the reporting cycle |
|---|---|---|---|
| 504 Certified Development Loans Approvals | 2025 |
|
|
| 7(a) Loan Guarantees Approvals | 2025 |
|
|
| 7(a) Loan Guarantees Purchases | 2025 |
|
|
| 7(j) Technical Assistance | * | ||
| 8(a) Business Development Program | * | ||
| Community Navigator Pilot Program | 2022 |
|
|
| Congressional Grants | 2023 |
|
|
| Cybersecurity for Small Business Pilot Program | * | ||
| Disaster Assistance Loans | 2025 |
|
|
| Economic Injury Disaster Loan Emergency Advance | 2023 |
|
|
| Federal and State Technology Partnership Program | * | ||
| Growth Accelerator Fund Competition | 2024 |
|
|
| HUBZone Program | * | ||
| Intermediary Loan Program | * | ||
| Microloan Program | 2020 |
|
|
| Native American Outreach | * | ||
| Ombudsman and Regulatory Fairness Boards | * | ||
| Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) Loan Forgiveness | 2025 |
|
|
| Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) Loan Guaranty Purchases | 2025 |
|
|
| Prime Technical Assistance | * | ||
| Regional Innovation Clusters | * | ||
| SBA Administrative Payroll | 2022 |
|
|
| SBA Administrative Travel | 2026 |
|
Yes |
| SBA Emerging Leaders initiative | * | ||
| SBA Other Administrative Spending | * | ||
| Service Corps of Retired Executives Program (SCORE) | * | ||
| Shuttered Venue Operators Grant Program | 2025 |
|
|
| Small Business Development Center (SBDC) | 2022 |
|
|
| Small Business Investment Companies Advances | 2022 |
|
|
| Small Business Investment Companies Purchases | * | ||
| State Trade Expansion Program | 2022 |
|
|
| Surety Bond Guarantees (SBG) | 2020 |
|
|
| Transition Assistance Entrepreneurship Track (Boots to Business) | * | ||
| Veterans Outreach Program | 2022 |
|
|
| Women's Business Ownership Assistance | 2022 |
|
* Assessment year is not displayed because one or more of the following statements is true:
- Not required to conduct a risk assessment under the Payment Integrity Information Act of 2019,
- Already assessed for improper payment risk under a different name in a prior reporting period, and/or
- New and planning to perform a risk assessment in the future.