Federal Communications Commission

In accordance with the Payment Integrity Information Act (PIIA) of 2019, the Commission has made significant efforts to implement policies and procedures to strengthen internal controls that prevent improper payments. In addition, the Commission utilizes a payment recapture program that includes both audits and transaction testing to search for and recapture overpayments. Although the Commission has made strides to improve policies, procedures and controls over improper payments, there is still more work to be done. For FY 2026, the Commission identified three phase 2 programs that meet the reporting criteria: Universal Service Fund (USF)-Lifeline, USF-High Cost Legacy, and Secured & Trusted Communications Network Reimbursement Program (STCNRP).

USF-High Cost Legacy: Although the program is still non-compliant with the PIIA of 2019, USF-High Cost Legacy remains a complex program, the improper payment rate has decreased from 3.26% to 1.82%. Strides have continued to be made to improve our efforts to reduce the improper payment rate. The Commission will continue to work on decreasing the amount of carriers using the incorrect depreciation method. This exception type remains the core issue that the Commission is actively working to address. In addition, special compliance reviews will continue to be made to identify methods to reduce the root causes of the improper payment rate. In the interim, corrective actions will continue to be taken such as using Risk Management Council Meetings to discuss strategic initiatives and risks, as well as conduct its annual Circle of Life webinars. The Commission is hopeful that the USF-High Cost Legacy Program will be compliant with the next couple of years.

USF-Lifeline: Unfortunately, the USF-Lifeline program remains non-compliant with the PIIA of 2019, as the improper rate estimate increased from 9.12% to 14.45%. The major causes of the improper payments are inadequate documentation related to usage. The major causes make up 73% of the improper payment rate. Examples of why the documentation was inadequate may include, but is not limited to, no usage during the 30 days prior to the snapshot date. The documentation provided does not demonstrate qualified usage during the 30 days prior to the snapshot date. The Commission and our Administrator, the Universal Service Administrative Company (USAC), the Lifeline program management continues to develop multiple outreach activities, including updates to the website training materials, conducting webinar(s) focused on common audit findings, prior program quality assurance (PQA) reviews and communicating best practices based on the observations. The Commission remains optimistic that the Lifeline Program will be compliant with the next couple of years.

STCNRP: FY 2026 was the first year that the Commission identified STCNRP as a phase 2 program; the program was determined to be compliant with the PIIA of 2019. Through testing, the improper payment rate estimate was determined to be 0.13%. This rate speaks to the sound procedures, practices, and systems in place that have led to the program being under the 1.5% threshold. Out of the sample identified, only one improper payment was identified. This payment was a duplicative payment that has since been corrected.

The Commission and its components continue to make great strides when it comes to oversight, internal control updates and implementation of policies and procedures. Our ultimate goal is to bring all of our programs back to phase 1 reporting requirements although there is more work to be done in order to reach the goal. With the Commission leadership, we continue to make much needed improvements in all of our programs each year. The Commission takes seriously the recommendations provided by our OIG and its auditor so that our programs are in compliance with the guidance outlined in OMB M-21-19.

In addition, the FCC does conduct Phase 1 risk assessment on a three-year cycle, unless the program has made significant changes in policy or funding. For FY 2026, the Commission did conduct four Phase 1 risk assessments for Telecommunications Relay Service, Federal Communications Commission Operating Expenses, USF-Cybersecurity Pilot Program, and USAC-Administrative Costs. All programs were deemed not susceptible to significant risk. Therefore, these programs will remain Phase 1 programs.

Show full executive summary
  • Federal Communications Commission improper payment estimates over time
    View as:

    Chart toggle amounts:
    Proper payments
    Overpayment
    Underpayment
    Technically improper
    Unknown

Recovery information

View as:

Chart toggle amounts:
Overpayment amount identified for recapture
Overpayment amount recovered

Recovery of overpayments

Please note: Overpayment amounts recovered are reported in the year they were recovered, not the year they were identified. Therefore it is possible in some years to have a recovery rate greater than 100%.

Overpayment amount identified through recovery activities $89.67 M
Overpayment amount recovered through recovery activities $5.1 M
Recovery activities recovery rate 5.69 %
Overpayment amount identified through recovery audits $8.73 M
Overpayment amount recovered through recovery audits $6.22 M
Recovery audit recovery rate 71.25 %
Overpayment amount identified for recapture $98.4 M
Overpayment amount recovered $11.32 M
Overpayment recovery rate 11.5 %

Conditions giving rise to improper payments identified in recovery audits, how those conditions are being resolved, and the methods used to recover those payments

There are a variety of conditions that arise during the audit process that
require the recovery of funds. Some of these reasons include but are not limited to
carrier/beneficiary not following or completely understanding the FCC's rules, invoicing
errors, eligibility requirements, duplicate subscribers, usage, competitive bidding issues,
inadequate documentation for assets, incorrect depreciation methods used, and equipment not
used for the intended purpose. There are also various methods used by the FCC to recover
funds. Some of these methods include but are not limited to demand letters, consent decrees,
credit memos, offsets, and notice of apparent liabilities (NALs).

The FCC continuously aims to use funds for their intended purpose.
When available, funds are returned to the appropriate account to be used for the intended
purpose.
Recovery audit amount identified this reporting period that remains outstanding $8.34 M
Recovery audit amount rate outstanding 95.53 %
Recovery audit amount this reporting period that remains outstanding for 0-6 months $4.56 M
Recovery audit amount identified this reporting period that remains outstanding for 6 months to 1 year $3.78 M
Recovery audit amount identified in this reporting period determined not collectible during this reporting period $0.0 M
Recovery audit rate identified in this reporting period determined not collectible during this reporting period 0 %

Intentional monetary loss improper payments are more commonly referred to as financial fraud and are overpayments that occur on purpose. This agency reported $33.52M of confirmed fraud in this reporting cycle.

Supplemental Information

The FCC has established several critical financial controls in place, including the US Treasury Do Not Pay (DNP) system. The agency utilizes DNP to verify the eligibility of payment recipients before disbursing funds as well as when onboarding new programs and vendors, thereby reducing the risk of improper payments. This has led to a reduced concerns in award processing. DNP is also used prior to making an award. For example, if a vendor does not have an active SAM.gov registration shown in the DNP system then the Commission will not issue the award. Although the Commission does not actively track the amount of savings as a result of using the DNP system, this is something that we will look to track in the future.

The Working System has reduced/prevented improper payments:

The Working System strives to maintain accurate data. However, the past year, FCC has identified incorrect information in the Working System Monthly.

FCC was found non-compliant during the most recent PIIA compliance review.

Non-compliant programs:

Show full list of compliant programs Expand

Compliant programs:

Actions recommended and planned to achieve compliance

The FY 2025 PIIA Audit Report identifies three findings resulting in eight recommendations. The FCC is actively working to address these findings and implement the recommendations proposed from the FCC OIG and its auditor. The Commission remains committed to making the necessary improvements to its programs and will work with its partners and the OIG to ensure improvements in compliance with OMB M-21-19. The primary recommendation to address the USF-High Cost Legacy IPR rate conduct its new Special Compliance Review (SCR) process to gain an understanding of the root cause behind the improper payment drivers. Each year, a sample of carriers will be selected for testing and analysis to identify the root causes of any improper payments. To further enhance program integrity, the High-Cost program will supplement the SCR with targeted outreach to carriers that have audit findings related to depreciation/documentation. Additionally, the Commission aims to reduce the USF-Lifeline Program rate. The plan is to meet this goal by implementing a Fraud Detection Tool to help identify potentially fraudulent data and documentation and implementing technical development and process updates for the USAC Lifeline National Verifier (NV) Application Programming Interface (API) internal controls to improve application quality and reduce improper payments. Finally, to implement improvements to the Commission’s IP reporting, the FCC plans to follow the recommendation to create a correction to allow time for secondary reviews through an enhanced quality control process prior to submission of the OMB Annual Data Call.


Official(s) accountable for the progress of the agency coming into compliance

Daniel Daly, the FCC Managing Director, is the official accountable for the progress of the agency in coming into compliance with PIIA.


Accountability mechanism tied to the success of the official designated in leading the efforts to come Into compliance

The FCC is committed to continually improving and strengthening the program integrity of its operations and the programs it oversees. The strategic goals outlined in the FCC FY 2027 Performance Plan and its FY 2026 – 2030 Strategic Plan have measurable performance indicators to ultimately reduce the improper payment error rates across FCC programs. Over the last several years the FCC has made numerous improvements in its programs to reduce improper payment rates. Although, the improper payment rates for all Phase 2 programs are not under the 1.5% threshold yet, one of those program’s rates did reduce this year and STCNRP’s improper payment rate debuted under the threshold. In addition, we continue to develop special compliance reviews to identify root causes to further reduce these rates in the coming years.


Program name When was the last improper payment risk assessment conducted? Likely to be susceptible to significant improper payments? Substantial changes made to the assessment methodology used for the reporting cycle
FCC Emergency Connectivity Fund (ECF) 2023 No No
FCC Secured & Trusted Communications Network Reimbursement Program (STCNRP) 2025 No Yes
Federal Communications Commission Operating Expenses 2026 No No
Telecommunications Relay Service 2026 No No
Universal Service Administrative Company (USAC) - Administrative Costs 2026 No No
Universal Service Fund - Connected Care Pilot Program *
Universal Service Fund - High Cost Legacy 2025 No Yes
Universal Service Fund - High Cost Modernized 2025 No No
Universal Service Fund - Rural Health Care 2025 No No
Universal Service Fund - Schools and Libraries 2024 No No
Universal Service Fund – Cybersecurity Pilot Program 2026 No No
Universal Service Fund – Lifeline 2025 No Yes

* Assessment year is not displayed because one or more of the following statements is true:

  1. Not required to conduct a risk assessment under the Payment Integrity Information Act of 2019,
  2. Already assessed for improper payment risk under a different name in a prior reporting period, and/or
  3. New and planning to perform a risk assessment in the future.

The FCC will continue to conduct improper payment risk assessments in accordance with the three year cycle plan. For FY 2027, the FCC will perform risk assessments for at least one of its phase one programs, assuming the programs meet the outlays threshold. However, the Commission will perform an off-cycle risk assessment if circumstances warrant such actions.