Emergency Conservation Program
Program level Payment Integrity results
Sponsoring agency: Department of Agriculture
View on Federal Program InventoryPROGRAM METRICS
$364 M
in FY 2026 outlays, with a
94.5%
payment accuracy rate
-
Improper payment estimates over time
View as:
Chart toggle amounts:Proper paymentsOverpaymentUnderpaymentTechnically improperUnknown
Payment Integrity results
-
FY 2026 improper payment estimates
Chart legend and breakdown
Payment accuracy rate
Improper payment rate
Unknown payment rate
Sampling & estimation methodology details
Sampling timeframe:
10/2024 - 09/2025
Confidence interval:
95% to <100%
Margin of error:
+/-3.097
Causes
A second major contributor was statutory or regulatory requirements not being met, particularly missing or invalid AD‑1026 (Highly Erodible Land Conservation (HELC) and Wetland Conservation (WC) Certification) forms, absent or incomplete environmental compliance documentation, and required signatures not obtained before approval. Because these documents directly impact eligibility, their absence automatically rendered payments improper, even when other aspects of the file were correct. In many states, these errors were compounded by unusual disaster types or infrequent ECP usage, leading to gaps in staff understanding of specific compliance triggers.
Lastly, employee accountability concerns, such as transposed numbers, incorrect acreages, missing certifications, and oversight during high‑workload periods, also played a significant role. Staffing shortages, turnover, or heavy disaster workloads were more likely susceptible to administrative mistakes which were avoidable. Some errors additionally arose from organizational alignment issues, such as county-to-county record transfers or obsolete state-level guidance, which created confusion or caused required documentation to be lost.
| Overpayment root cause | Overpayment amount |
|---|---|
| Amount of overpayments within the agency's control | $6.36 M |
| Amount of overpayments outside the agency's control | $0.0 M |
| Amount of overpayments that occurred because the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment does not exist | $0.0 M |
| Amount of overpayments that occurred because of an inability to access the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment | $0.0 M |
| Amount of overpayments that occurred because of a failure to access data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment | $6.36 M |
| Underpayment root cause | Underpayment amount |
|---|---|
| Amount of underpayments | $0.68 M |
| The amount of underpayments that occurred because the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment does not exist | $0.0 M |
| The amount of underpayments that occurred because of an inability to access the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment | $0.0 M |
| The amount of underpayments that occurred because of a failure to access data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment | $0.68 M |
| The amount of improper payments that were paid to the right recipient for the correct amount but were considered technically improper because of failure to follow statute or regulation | $12.8 M |
| The amount that could either be proper or improper but the agency is unable to determine whether it was proper or improper as a result of insufficient or lack of documentation | $0.0 M |
Prevention
Automation (completed Jan. 2024, and will affect all payments made through the ECP software. Only payments issued through the older Cost Share Software had findings this year). These changes directly mitigate errors tied to failure to access or properly apply information, which accounted for the majority of overpayments.
-ECP software restricts the payment scenarios presented to the user for selection to only those that are authorized for use for the disaster year and practice
-ECP software has an automated allowable cost validation to reduce miscalculations and eliminate incorrect Cost Share payments
-ECP software reduces manual data entry points to mitigate human errors
-ECP software increases the use of documentation and compliance prompts to ensure verification of AD-1026 (Highly Erodible Land Conservation (HELC) and Wetland Conservation (WC) Certification), CCC-860 (Socially Disadvantaged, Limited Resource, Beginning, and Veteran Farmer or Rancher Certification), CCC-902/3 (Farm Operating Plan-Individual/Entity) forms, and environmental compliance
Behavioral/Psych Influence (completed Jan. 2025, and will affect all payments issued from this date). Behavioral and process‑based controls were strengthened to address oversight issues identified in the root‑cause analysis.
-Established checklist requirement prior to each approval and each payment
-Established supervisory checklist review requirements, including mandatory County Executive Director (CED), District Director and State Office review layers
-Checklist requirement of documentation and compliance prompts to ensure verification of AD‑1026, CCC‑860, signatures, and environmental compliance forms prior to payment approval.
Training (Throughout FY 2026). These actions directly mitigated confusion arising from misinterpreted state guidance or infrequent ECP use.
-Delivered targeted training to Hurricane states with high workload and unfamiliarity with the program (Oct.-Dec. 2025)
-Delivered targeted training nationwide during monthly calls to State and County employees (Feb. – Sept. 2026)
-Change Process (completed Apr. 2026) This measure addresses findings of failure to access data/information related to overpayment, and environmental compliance findings, which were 46 percent of the findings.
-Simplified the FSA-23 (Determining Agricultural Market Value and Cost Share Worksheet) and the agricultural market value payment limitation documentation.
-ER850 (Environmental Screening Worksheet) certification by State Environmental Coordinators (SEC) now includes a certification statement so the form will be used correctly in the state.
Cross Enterprise Sharing (completed Feb. 2026) These measures address organizational alignment root causes, particularly fragmented documentation and inconsistent state interpretations.
-Application Program Interface (API) with Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) for payment scenario data. With direct data transfer, it mitigates the risk of mistakes during data entry.
-NRCS has direct access to the ECP software to complete the needs determinations and certifications of completion to standard.
Statutory Changes (completed Apr. 2026). These measures address forty-six percent of the findings related to environmental compliance.
-7 CFR Part 1b revisions to regulations to unify USDA’s National Environmental Policy Act procedures, enhance flexibility, inject transparency and accountability with timeline caps, and streamline administrative processes through applicant-prepared documentation, all while emphasizing consistent, department-wide environmental compliance.
FSA Corrective Actions Planned
In FY 2027, FSA will focus on strengthening process controls and behavioral‑based corrective actions to address the root causes of improper payments identified in FY 2026.
Behavioral/Psych Influence (FY 2027 Q2)
-Updated national guidance will be issued to reinforce required supervisory review layers (CED, District Director, and State Office oversight) and ensure consistent verification of documentation such as AD‑1026, CCC‑902, CCC‑860, and environmental compliance forms prior to payment.
-ER850 certification by State Environmental Coordinators (SEC) now includes a certification statement as the form will be used correctly in the state. In addition, when an ER850 is issued, it is recommended that the SEC will conduct training with the counties prior to use of the environmental compliance document for ECP applications.
Training (FY 2027 Q1,Q2, Q3, Q4)
-Training will continue to be a major component of planned corrective actions. FSA will deliver additional scenario‑based training focused on the most frequent documentation and eligibility errors, including state-specific training for correct use of ER850, timing requirements for loading CCC‑860 into subsidiary files, and proper certification of extent for completed practices.
Change Process (FY 2027 Q3)
-Clarify policy to state the CC-860 needs to be entered into the system prior to payment, rather than simply being on file.
Collectively, these actions taken and planned actions directly target behavioral, training, and process‑related root causes and will strengthen internal controls while promoting consistent national delivery of ECP.
The corrective actions taken for FY 2026 are proportional to both the severity and the dollar value of the root causes, particularly the estimated $6.36M in overpayments and $0.68M in underpayments attributed primarily to Failure to Access Data/Information and human error. The following are actions taken/planned by FSA for ECP:
-Automation enhancements, such as restricting payment scenario options to only authorized fiscal‑year scenarios and adding allowable‑cost validations, directly address high‑dollar root causes by removing opportunities for the most frequent and costly errors. These system changes are proportionate because they target the exact points in the workflow where payment miscalculations previously occurred and prevent recurrence regardless of staff turnover or workload.
-Expanded training on AD‑1026 (Highly Erodible Land Conservation (HELC) and Wetland Conservation (WC) Certification) requirements, environmental compliance documentation, and proper use of system enhancements was implemented because training gaps were a significant contributor to improper payments identified in the root‑cause analysis.
-Behavioral‑influence actions, including strengthening County Executive Director (CED), District Director (DD), and State Office review layers, were scaled to the seriousness of cases involving missing signatures, incomplete eligibility documentation, and certification errors. Process change efforts, such as improvements to the FSA‑23 (Determining Agricultural Market Value and Cost Share Worksheet) form to determine payment limitation by agricultural value, are proportionate to organizational‑alignment issues that contributed to missing or misplaced eligibility documentation. These actions are appropriately weighted because such issues led to high‑impact improper payments, particularly in states where documentation had been transferred or maintained inconsistently.
Collectively, the level of corrective action corresponds to the size and nature of the root causes, ensuring that the most resource‑intensive strategies were deployed where the monetary exposure was greatest. By directly targeting employee accountability concerns, information access failures, and structural process weaknesses, the corrective actions taken provide coverage proportional to the severity of the improper‑payment rates and their underlying drivers.
The agency’s prioritization of corrective actions directly reflects the severity and frequency of root‑cause patterns identified in the FY26 review. Automation was prioritized because Failure to Access Data/Information and human error represented the majority of improper payments, and eliminating manual entry points was the most effective way to prevent recurrence. Training and cross‑enterprise sharing actions were prioritized next because unfamiliarity with documentation requirements and inconsistent state-level interpretations contributed to several large overpayments. Early results indicate these combined actions are effective: improper payment rates have already shown a drastic decline, demonstrating that the corrective actions meaningfully mitigate the underlying causes of payment errors. Together, these steps form a coordinated implementation strategy that strengthens internal controls, enhances staff competency, and ensures consistent national compliance moving forward.
| Payment type | Mitigation strategies taken | Mitigation strategies planned |
|---|---|---|
| Overpayments | Automation, Behavioral/Psych Influence, Change Process, Cross Enterprise Sharing, Statutory Change, Training | Behavioral/Psych Influence, Training |
| Underpayments | Automation, Behavioral/Psych Influence, Cross Enterprise Sharing, Training | Behavioral/Psych Influence, Change Process, Training |
| Technically improper payments | Automation, Behavioral/Psych Influence, Training | Behavioral/Psych Influence, Training |
| Eligibility element/information needed | Description of the eligbility element/information |
|---|---|
| Other | Properly selected National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) Categorical Exclusions were misunderstood. |
Additional information
The agency reviewed and refined FY 2026 testing criteria so that payments are evaluated solely against statute and regulation, consistent with OMB Memorandum M-21-19. This update will result in more accurate and compliant assessments of improper payments. This refinement is a critical driver of our reduced improper payment rates in FY 2026. By aligning testing strictly with statutory and regulatory requirements, this ensures improper payments are accurate and compliant with regulatory criteria.
The Agency notes that full implementation of this plan is contingent on available staffing and resources. Like many federal programs operating within evolving budget environments, Emergency Conservation Program (ECP) will continue adapting implementation timelines and oversight procedures based on capacity constraints, while prioritizing core program integrity functions.
Many identified corrective actions to bring ECP into compliance have been completed. However, specific actions such as software enhancements that are not effective until FY26 and will not impact ECP improper payment testing results until FY27.
Reduction target
5.0 %The Emergency Conservation Program (ECP) currently has the internal controls necessary to reduce improper and unknown payments to levels where further reductions would cost more to achieve than the amount they would save. Recent automation enhancements, such as restricting payment scenario selections, embedding allowable‑cost validations, and strengthening supervisory review layers, provide adequate risk mitigation and align internal controls with the actual root causes identified in FY 2026. Human capital capacity has been reinforced through targeted AD‑1026 (Highly Erodible Land Conservation (HELC) and Wetland Conservation (WC) Certification) and compliance training, as well as clearer policy guidance, ensuring staff have the knowledge needed to maintain the improved control environment. Additionally, ongoing information system improvements have continued refinement of ECP software, provide sufficient infrastructure to sustain payment integrity performance without requiring additional investment. The Agency notes that full implementation of this plan is contingent on available staffing and resources. Like many federal programs operating within evolving budget environments, ECP will continue adapting implementation timelines and oversight procedures based on capacity constraints, while prioritizing core program integrity functions.
The Emergency Conservation Program (ECP) program did not submit a budget request for FY 2026 related to payment‑integrity needs because current internal controls, staffing capacity, and system infrastructure are sufficient to maintain improper payment levels within acceptable thresholds. Recent automation updates, including payment scenario restrictions and allowable cost validations, were implemented within existing system resources, and planned improvements are being developed through ongoing enterprise modernization efforts. Staff training needs have been met through updated curriculum delivered in FY 2026, and no additional funding is required to sustain these improvements. As a result, the program has the resources necessary to maintain and further reduce improper payments without requiring new or expanded budget authority.
Farm Programs (DAFP) has partnered with Field Operations (DAFO) to improve our accountability efforts with the following actions:
-FSA leadership will collaborate to enforce employee accountability for repetitive administrative errors affecting the PIIA error rate. Evaluation of the administrative errors will include identifying the state and/or county where the errors are occurring and recurring, including identifying the employees responsible for the administrative errors and certifying and signing improper payments. Supervisors will be held accountable to document the deficiencies in the employees’ performance evaluations.
-It is imperative that field offices realize the importance of course correction on administrative errors and what steps will necessitate course correction to employees who continue to cause administrative errors. FSA’s DAFP must partner with DAFO to support local oversight, improvement, and implement accountability measures. A methodology for course correction will be necessary.
-DAFP will utilize the following payment integrity dashboard views: Common Findings, Findings by Programs, PIIA Rates by Programs and PIIA Findings by States, to determine the extent of FY 2026 payment errors related to administrative functions in the field offices.
-DAFO will assist with enforcing DAFP policies to address program non-compliance issues. Additionally, DAFO supports accountability measures and will require that states are accountable to recommendations in approved Corrective Action Plans.