Federal Employees Health Benefits - Experience Rated Carriers
Program level Payment Integrity results
Sponsoring agency: Office of Personnel Management
PROGRAM METRICS
$71,371 M
in FY 2026 outlays, with a
99.6%
payment accuracy rate
-
Improper payment estimates over time
View as:
Chart toggle amounts:Proper paymentsOverpaymentUnderpaymentTechnically improperUnknown
Payment Integrity results
-
FY 2026 improper payment estimates
Chart legend and breakdown
Payment accuracy rate
Improper payment rate
Unknown payment rate
Sampling & estimation methodology details
Sampling timeframe:
10/2024 - 12/2025
Confidence interval:
95% to <100%
Margin of error:
+/-2.5
Causes
Carriers reported a variety of specific root causes for each of the root cause types identified above. These include human errors, system errors, and recordkeeping errors. Scenarios of human errors include improper application of Medicare Allowance to members covered by Medicare, improper application of coordination of benefits, and improper application of retroactive provider agreements. Scenarios of system errors and recordkeeping errors include contract terms not being entered into systems timely, records not being maintained, coordination of benefits being applied improperly, issues arising from platform migration, identified required adjustments not being performed, and allocation methodologies not being updated to account for the PSHB Program.
| Overpayment root cause | Overpayment amount |
|---|---|
| Amount of overpayments within the agency's control | $0.0 M |
| Amount of overpayments outside the agency's control | $78.27 M |
| Amount of overpayments that occurred because the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment does not exist | $0.0 M |
| Amount of overpayments that occurred because of an inability to access the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment | $0.71 M |
| Amount of overpayments that occurred because of a failure to access data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment | $77.56 M |
| Underpayment root cause | Underpayment amount |
|---|---|
| Amount of underpayments | $63.12 M |
| The amount of underpayments that occurred because the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment does not exist | $0.0 M |
| The amount of underpayments that occurred because of an inability to access the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment | $0.05 M |
| The amount of underpayments that occurred because of a failure to access data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment | $63.07 M |
| The amount of improper payments that were paid to the right recipient for the correct amount but were considered technically improper because of failure to follow statute or regulation | $32.15 M |
| The amount that could either be proper or improper but the agency is unable to determine whether it was proper or improper as a result of insufficient or lack of documentation | $130.25 M |
Prevention
Most corrective actions identified by Carriers have already been taken, but some have completion dates in the future. Carriers are required to report on prior years’ findings annually. OPM will monitor future reports from carriers to identify whether the CAPs have been effective in reducing improper and unknown payments.
Carriers are required to identify the root cause type for all identified improper payments. Corrective action plans also identify actions either planned or taken to prevent repeated occurrence of the causes of IPs and UPs. OPM does not require Carriers to pursue recoveries for identified IPs when the cost of pursuing those recoveries will exceed the value of the funds recovered.
Most of the corrective actions planned and taken by Carriers involve changes in processes and training directed at the root causes of the IPs and UPs. The types of root causes typically included failure to access data, inability to determine if the payment was proper and failing to meet statutory requirements. Corrective actions typically include automation, behavioral/psychological influences, and auditing to identify and correct errors. The value of process changes and training which is directed at the root causes can be estimated by projecting the savings to the program similar to how the projected improper payment is estimated. For example, an individual overpayment of $25 may result in a statistical projection of over $140,000 in overpayments for a carrier in a year. A process change that successfully prevents future overpayments from the same root cause would save approximately $140,000 the following year, and in subsequent years. Carriers are expected to use this type of analysis to ensure that the level of corrective action proportionate to the savings anticipated to be realized.
In a review of the FY2025 Corrective Action Plans, HI noted many instances where Carriers either planned or have taken actions to implement policy changes or trainings to mitigate or eliminate future IPs and UPs based on their root cause analyses. Carriers have reported corrections and recoveries of numerous specific overpayments identified in the sampling and testing.
| Payment type | Mitigation strategies taken | Mitigation strategies planned |
|---|---|---|
| Overpayments | Audit, Change Process, Training | Audit, Automation, Change Process, Training |
| Underpayments | Audit, Change Process, Training | Audit, Automation, Change Process, Training |
| Technically improper payments | Audit, Change Process, Training | Change Process, Training |
| Unknown payments | Automation, Training, Change Process, Audit | Training, Change Process |
| Eligibility element/information needed | Description of the eligbility element/information |
|---|---|
| Financial | The financial position or status of a beneficiary, recipient, or their family |
| Military Status | The condition of being, or having been in the uniformed services |
| Receiving Benefits from Other Sources | Beneficiary or recipient is receiving benefits from an additional source |
Additional information
Reduction target
0.29 %HI has continued to adjust workloads and priorities for staff to maintain mission critical operations while operating with fewer resources. HI has strengthened its contracts with carriers regarding identification and recovery of overpayments outside the statistical sampling for PIIA Reporting. As additional information becomes available and new oversight activities begin, HI will evaluate the human capital requirements and information systems necessary to ensure the costs of reducing and recovering IPs do not exceed the amounts prevented or recovered. HI continues to leverage technology to streamline processes, improve precision, and further develop in-house expertise necessary to stay in compliance with PIIA, while minimizing amounts paid to outside contractors. OPM plans to continue these efforts and to leverage lessons learned in developing and implementing its Sampling and Estimation Methodology Plan to minimize IPs and maximize program oversight. As potential improvements are identified, the costs and resources required to implement changes to achieve those improvements will be evaluated to determine whether costs associated with preventing and recovering IPs would exceed the value of the improper payments prevented and recovered.
OPM’s budget submission did not request specific resources to establish and maintain payment integrity for the Experience-Rated Activity. OPM has numerous mechanisms in place to prevent and recover improper payments. OPM will use existing personnel and resources to analyze the data being collected to establish a baseline, identify a tolerable rate and maintain or improve the improper payment and unknown payment rate and therefore has not made a budget request.
OPM is committed to effective oversight and administration of all its activities. The structure of the Experience-Rated Activity is one in which the individual Carriers bear the risk of claims, not the Federal Government. This structure serves dual purposes of mitigating risk to the government and incentivizing Carriers to minimize improper payments. In addition, OPM requires Carriers to proactively identify erroneous payments through robust internal controls and statistically valid reviews. Those requirements are in addition to the statistically valid sampling and testing the Experience-Rated Activity requires of Carriers to provide the data necessary to produce a statistically valid IP estimate. Additionally, OPM requires Carriers to take prompt and diligent actions to recover erroneous payments and to report on the average time between the discovery of an erroneous payment and the initiation of recovery efforts for the erroneous payment. Failure of Carriers to act timely to recover erroneous payments will negatively impact their performance assessment scores and may result in charges to the program being disallowed. Carriers’ failure to comply with contract requirements and respond to OPM inquiries can also impact Carriers’ performance assessments, which impacts the Carriers’ service fees.
OPM is working to establish a baseline and is on track to continue the process for obtaining statistically valid IP estimates for the Experience-Rated Activity. Since baseline data is not available, OPM’s reduction target for FY2027 has been established by determining what the ER Carrier Activity IP and UP rate would have been if all carriers had reported the results of sampling and testing. The Contracting Office and Payment Integrity Team intend to work with the Carrier to ensure that required sampling, testing, and reporting are completed. If the Carrier is not compliant next year, HI will consider additional actions with respect to the Carrier. Additionally, if the reduction target is not met, HI will evaluate whether it has sufficient information to establish a baseline. If so, OPM will establish a baseline, and evaluate the data collected to identify any program wide changes or carrier specific changes that may reduce improper and unknown payments and establish a reduction target that is both aggressive and realistic given the practical limitations of the payment systems.