Project-Based Rental Assistance (PBRA)

High-priority program

Program level Payment Integrity results

Sponsoring agency: Department of Housing and Urban Development

View on Federal Program Inventory

PROGRAM METRICS

$16,962 M

in FY 2026 outlays, with a

88.4%

payment accuracy rate

  • Improper payment estimates over time
    View as:

    Chart toggle amounts:
    Proper payments
    Overpayment
    Underpayment
    Technically improper
    Unknown

Payment Integrity results

  • FY 2026 improper payment estimates

    Chart legend and breakdown

    Payment accuracy rate

    Improper payment rate

    Unknown payment rate


    Sampling & estimation methodology details

    Sampling timeframe:

    10/2024 - 09/2025


    Confidence interval:

    95% to <100%


    Margin of error:

    +/-4.02

Causes

HUD identified the following root causes related to the inability to access data or information stored with third-party administrators:

- For improper payments, HUD identified instances where the Property Owner used incorrect income, asset, or deduction information, incorrect payment standards for a rent reasonableness determination, or the tenant was otherwise ineligible due to missing annual recertification or citizenship verifications.
- For technically improper payments, the Property Owner was missing an Enterprise Income Verification (EIV) report to support tenant eligibility.
- For unknown payments, the Property Owner was missing tenant file materials to support tenant eligibility (e.g., income, asset, deduction, citizenship documentation).

Overpayment root cause Overpayment amount
Amount of overpayments within the agency's control $0.0 M
Amount of overpayments outside the agency's control $171.32 M
Amount of overpayments that occurred because the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment does not exist $0.0 M
Amount of overpayments that occurred because of an inability to access the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment $171.32 M
Amount of overpayments that occurred because of a failure to access data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment $0.0 M

Underpayment root cause Underpayment amount
Amount of underpayments $29.49 M
The amount of underpayments that occurred because the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment does not exist $0.0 M
The amount of underpayments that occurred because of an inability to access the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment $29.49 M
The amount of underpayments that occurred because of a failure to access data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment $0.0 M

The amount of improper payments that were paid to the right recipient for the correct amount but were considered technically improper because of failure to follow statute or regulation $730.05 M

The amount that could either be proper or improper but the agency is unable to determine whether it was proper or improper as a result of insufficient or lack of documentation $1,041.8 M

Prevention

HUD's corrective action strategy in fiscal year (FY) 2026 focused on addressing the conditions that caused noncompliance and moving the Department from reactive review toward prevention, early detection, and continuous monitoring.

Rental Assistance Data Accuracy & Risk (RADAR) Dashboard: In FY 2026, HUD implemented the RADAR dashboard to provide centralized visibility into anomalies and risk indicators across the Multifamily Housing Project-Based Rental Assistance program. RADAR improves visibility into tenant-level and payment information that was previously fragmented across systems and external administrators, enabling HUD to identify inconsistent data, incomplete records, and potential eligibility concerns earlier, monitor risk indicators across programs, and prioritize high-risk transactions for follow-up and remediation. This centralized view strengthens HUD’s ability to more proactively oversee recurring payment integrity risks, such as payments for deceased tenants or individuals with nonconforming social security numbers, by tracking trends over time, highlighting persistent vulnerabilities, and providing visibility into actions taken to address them.

SAM.gov Unique Entity Identifier (UEI) Validation Automation: HUD implemented automation to validate SAM.gov registration status and proactive notifications to recipients in the rental assistance programs. The SAM.gov validation automation helps HUD continue to monitor recipient eligibility by providing advanced visibility into SAM.gov registration expirations, enabling timely intervention to prevent lapses, and helping reduce avoidable compliance risks. This control is intended to reduce the likelihood that payments are made to inactive or noncompliant entities and strengthen front-end controls over recipient eligibility and payment processing.

In FY 2027, HUD will focus on establishing the foundation for corrective actions that address the underlying structural complexities, including assessing proposals to simplify complex policies, evaluating the viability of technology modernizations, and providing targeted trainings.

Simplification of Complex Program Requirements: HUD will assess policies and regulations that contribute to the complexity and variation within HUD’s rental assistance programs by September 30, 2027. In collaboration with relevant program offices and the Office of General Counsel, HUD will develop a current-state assessment of rent payment components and authorizing policies, including tenant recertifications, housing assistance payment calculations, fair market rent requirements, and utility allowances. HUD will use this assessment to identify proposals to change policy and operations that can simplify requirements and reduce root causes of error.

Technology Modernization: Through September 30, 2027, HUD will evaluate the viability of establishing a technology infrastructure that enables the upload and maintenance of tenant-level eligibility and payment documentation from recipients to HUD, performs data validation and subsidy calculations, and reviews and analyzes payment evidence. HUD will also assess approaches for collecting recipient and subrecipient payment details to support greater visibility into tenants and property owners. This transparency into rental assistance payments will allow HUD to strengthen program integrity, by gathering meaningful insights into who HUD is paying and ensuring rental assistance is making its way to the people who need it the most.

Training and Technical Assistance: HUD will perform a gap analysis on the existing training and technical assistance program currently available to property owners, management agents and contract administrators and provide a recommendations report to third-party training providers by September 30, 2027. The analysis and recommendations will focus on eligibility determinations, payment calculations, documentation retention, and timely updates to tenant and recipient information. The objective is to identify opportunities to reduce areas of noncompliance.

The corrective actions planned for fiscal year 2027 are strategically designed to address the root causes of HUD’s improper and unknown payments, reflecting a proportional response to the severity of these issues.

Improper Payments ($200.803M): Complex policies lead to incorrect income, asset, and deduction information being used and ultimately improper payments disbursed from HUD. Therefore, HUD plans to identify and assess governing policies and regulations that impact payment integrity in order to simplify policy requirements.

Technically Improper Payments ($730.054M): When technical procedural steps are not followed, such as maintaining timely run Enterprise Income Verification (EIV) reports, this results in technically improper payments from HUD. Therefore, HUD plans to identify targeted training and technical assistance opportunities to reinforce accountability among entities responsible for payment integrity.

Unknown Payments ($1,041.795M): When documentation to support tenant eligibility is missing, such as the tenant file (e.g., income, asset, deduction, citizenship documentation), this results in unknown / unsupported payments disbursed from HUD. Therefore, HUD plans to evaluate the viability of establishing a technology infrastructure to modernize the collection and evaluation of tenant documentation and enhance payment integrity compliance.

HUD remains committed to fulfilling its mission to create strong, sustainable, inclusive communities and quality, affordable homes for all while ensuring that payments made in support of that mission are made proper, supported and accountable. HUD has coordinated senior leadership across OCFO, PIH and MFH to oversee prioritization and implementation of these corrective actions and monitor progress toward compliance.

HUD conducted extensive validation work on potential payment errors identified through its fiscal year (FY) 2025 analytics. This work included transaction-level follow-up, reconciliation of discrepancies with program partners, targeted outreach to property owners, and contract administrators, and review of tenant status, eligibility, and payment conditions. As a result of this validation effort, HUD significantly reduced the universe of unresolved anomalies and improved its understanding of the underlying causes of identified payment risks, allowing the Department to focus corrective actions on the highest-risk areas.

The corrective actions implemented in FY 2026, Rental Assistance Data Accuracy & Risk (RADAR) and the SAM.gov Automation, represented a broader shift toward stronger data quality, earlier intervention, and more durable program controls. RADAR helps HUD identify inconsistent data, incomplete records, and potential eligibility concerns earlier, so high-risk transactions can be prioritized for follow-up and remediation. By improving visibility into information that was previously fragmented across systems and external administrators, RADAR is helping HUD shift from reactive review to proactive risk management. The SAM.gov Unique Entity Identifier (UEI) Validation Automation reduces the likelihood that payments will be associated with inactive or noncompliant registrations and reinforces front-end controls over recipient eligibility and payment processing.

HUD will continue the success of FY 2026 into FY 2027 to address the root causes of the improper, unknown, and technically improper payments. To streamline policies impacting payment integrity, HUD will assess the policies and regulations governing tenant recertifications, housing assistance payment calculations, fair market rent requirements, and utility allowances to reduce complexities. HUD will evaluate the viability of establishing a technology infrastructure to enable the upload, validation and analysis of payment evidence, and assess approaches for collecting recipient and subrecipient payment details to support greater visibility into tenants and property owners. Additionally, HUD will identify targeted training for recipients focused on eligibility determinations, payment calculations, documentation retention, and timely updates to tenant and recipient information. Together, these initiatives will support HUD’s continued efforts to produce a compliant payment integrity estimate, improve payment accuracy, and strengthen program administration

Payment type Mitigation strategies taken Mitigation strategies planned
Overpayments Automation Change Process, Statutory Change, Training
Underpayments Automation Change Process, Statutory Change, Training
Technically improper payments Automation, Change Process Change Process, Statutory Change, Training
Unknown payments Automation Training, Change Process, Statutory Change

Eligibility element/information needed Description of the eligbility element/information
Citizenship Recognized as a United States citizen through birth or naturalization, or as a lawfully present non-citizen in the United States
Employment The employment status of the recipient/beneficiary
Financial The financial position or status of a beneficiary, recipient, or their family
Identity Able to establish that someone is uniquely who they claim to be
Medical Status Identifies whether a person is sick/healthy
Other The tenant file contains evidence of the tenant's eligibility in the program. In addition to the data reflected on this list, the following information would have helped prevent improper payments: Income data (e.g., from W-2 and 1099) 1099 reporting from the Department of the Treasury, including legal entity name and Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN) for 1099 reporting Social Security Number (SSN) verification, including the issue date and the individual’s name, from the Social Security Administration to each tenant Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits and other relevant data from the Department of Agriculture (USDA) Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) and Tribal TANF benefits and other relevant data from the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Child Support payments and benefits data from HHS Veteran benefits information from the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) Debts due to the federal government from the Department of the Treasury Immigration and U.S. citizenship information from the Department of Homeland Security, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) Systematic Alien Verification Entitlements (SAVE) With direct access to the tenant file and other supporting information, HUD would be able to validate the housing assistance subsidy and tenant eligibility, confirm payment eligibility prior to payment, and ultimately better prevent improper payments.
Receiving Benefits from Other Sources Beneficiary or recipient is receiving benefits from an additional source
Residency Status of recipient's living location or arrangement

Additional information

In fiscal year (FY) 2025, HUD's Project Based Rental Assistance Program (PBRA) was accounted for under a single program, Housing - Rental Housing Assistance Program (RHAP) - Project Based Rental Assistance - Project Based Section 8 - Rental Housing Assistance Program- Section 236 - Housing for Persons with Disability- Section 811 Program. In accordance with OMB guidance for the Federal Program Inventory, HUD split that program into seven ALN/programs for FY 2026 reporting, PBRA is the only one that continued reporting an improper payment estimate in FY 2026.

In fiscal year (FY) 2026, HUD targeted its estimation methodology toward transaction-level testing and leveraged the results of the HUD's Office of the Inspector General's (OIG) independent audit Report: 2026-BO-0002, HUD’s Multifamily Project-Based Rental Assistance Program Had Significant Improper Payments, to prepare its FY 2026 improper and unknown payment estimate. Through this audits, HUD OIG sought to determine whether housing assistance payments (HAP) in the PBRA programs are proper. HUD OIG selected a sample based on a one-month population of active head of household program participants and tested payments to verify tenant eligibility, payment amount, and compliance with HUD requirements. HUD’s improper and unknown payment estimate was developed based upon OIG’s testing results.

A statistically valid one-month sample estimate was annualized (i.e. multiplied by 12) to reach an estimate for the full year. The margin of error of 4.02% is based on the statistically valid one-month sample estimate.

Reduction target

10.0 %

The agency has many of the essential components needed to reduce improper payments and unknown payments. While HUD made remarkable strides in fiscal year (FY) 2026, significant issues still remain and enhancements in policy reform, information systems, and stakeholder training are needed to continue to improve payment integrity. In FY 2025 HUD launched Project Voucher, a whole-of-agency transformation effort to improve the integrity and efficiency of its rental assistance programs. Into FY 2027 the initiative continues its aim to eliminate fraud, waste, and abuse, maximize resources, and ensure responsible stewardship of taxpayer dollars, while establishing greater visibility and traceability in rental assistance payments.

In FY 2027, HUD will focus on establishing the foundation for corrective actions that address the underlying structural complexities, including assessing proposals to simplify complex policies, evaluating the viability of technology modernizations, and identifying targeted trainings. Together, these projects will aim to further reveal the additional internal controls, human capital, information systems, and other policy and infrastructure needs required to reduce improper and unknown payments.

By strengthening these areas, the agency aims to achieve a level of reduction in improper and unknown payments that justifies the associated expenditures. This approach ensures that the cost of implementing further controls do not exceed the savings gained from preventing or recovering improper payments. These projects represent a significant commitment to enhancing program integrity, preventing future payment errors, and ensuring federal funds are allocated to eligible recipients.

The 2027 Budget includes a significant investment of $30 million in payment integrity efforts in alignment with this Administration’s objective to safeguard taxpayer dollars. To support the efforts associated with Executive Order 14249, Protecting America's Bank Account Against Fraud, Waste, and Abuse, HUD will strategically deploy this funding to protect against financial fraud and prevent improper payments. This funding will enable HUD to begin to implement its strategy to improve the Department’s financial integrity. The planned capabilities are discussed in further detail below:
Recipient and Sub-recipient Reporting:
-Builds upon the sub-recipient reporting pilot started in 2025, this effort mitigates longstanding, inherent risks in HUD program design where programs are frequently administered by a third party and usually involve complex projects and often with one or more tiers of sub-grantees. HUD is expanding sub-recipient reporting to all grant recipients in a phased approach beginning in 2026 with the buildout of tools and business processes. HUD plans to begin onboarding grant recipients to this enhanced reporting process starting in 2026 and continuing in 2027.
-Provides a secure, simplified, and standardized portal for recipients to submit financial evidence and supporting documentation for disbursements, including evidence of sub-recipient and vendor spending.
-Amplifies HUD staff ability to perform adequate and thorough grant oversight by enabling analytics that identify anomalies and risks and automating parts of compliance reviews and financial monitoring. By extending this monitoring all the way to the sub-recipient spending level, this will also improve HUD’s payment integrity posture.

Project Voucher:
-Provides a secure, standardized mechanism for Public Housing Authorities (PHAs) and Performance-Based Contract Administrators to submit tenant- and household level eligibility information required to administer HUD-assisted housing programs.
-Establishes a system of record for tenant and family eligibility data submitted by PHAs. It supports historical tracking of eligibility determinations and changes over time to ensure transparency, auditability, and program integrity.
-Allows for analysis of tenant eligibility data to support oversight, compliance monitoring, and risk identification across PHAs and programs. It provides visibility into patterns, anomalies, and trends that may indicate errors, inconsistencies, or potential noncompliance.
-Enables data analysis and gathering of self-reported data from tenants/families and recipients and sub-recipients, supported by evidence such as check and payment records from PHAs to landlords and recipients to sub-recipients.
-The tool will analyze and review data, documents, and evidence to verify eligibility for HUD’s programs and facilitate the mapping of relationships between tenant and landlord (and recipient and sub-recipient) payments, while also analyzing interactions between PHA leadership and landlords and tenants (and recipients and sub-recipients).

Business Process and Change Management:
-Across the three workstreams identified above, funding will also support technical and contractual support to facilitate the necessary business process updates across the HUD program portfolio in alignment with the payment integrity initiative. This includes training of internal and external stakeholders, development of operating procedures and handbooks, and user support.

In HUD’s Audit Management Systems (AMS), Headquarters’ Primary Organization Heads (HPOHs) assign Program Office Management Points of Contact and Audit Liaison Officers to manage Single Audit Act (SAA) responsibilities. Assigned Program staff are responsible for developing and submitting management letters to auditees regarding resolution findings in their single audit report associated with an Assistance Listing Number (ALN) and working with auditees to ensure reports are submitted timely and findings are resolved. Audit Liaison Officers are responsible for approving the closure of findings where applicable. Audits are performed in accordance with the Single Audit Act (31 U.S.C. Chapter 75) and the Uniform Guidance audit requirements in 2 CFR Part 200, Subpart F, which govern how federal award recipients are evaluated by independent auditors. The submission, monitoring, and tracking of findings resulting from these audit reports are under the direct authority and responsibility of each applicable HPOH and are tracked in HUD's audit tracking system's SAA module. HUD’s Departmental Single Audit Act policy requires all program offices to use the SAA module for documenting and tracking Single Audit reviews. SAA audits can involve more than one program, agency, or State and local governments, etc. Entities receiving federal financial assistance may be required to have an audit performed in accordance with the SAA of 1984 as amended and the OMB Circular A-133.

$759.54 M