DOW - Military Retirement - Retired Pay

Program level Payment Integrity results

Sponsoring agency: Department of War

PROGRAM METRICS

$65,731 M

in FY 2026 outlays, with a

99.9%

payment accuracy rate

  • Improper payment estimates over time
    View as:

    Chart toggle amounts:
    Proper payments
    Overpayment
    Underpayment
    Technically improper
    Unknown

Payment Integrity results

  • FY 2026 improper payment estimates

    Chart legend and breakdown

    Payment accuracy rate

    Improper payment rate

    Unknown payment rate


    Sampling & estimation methodology details

    Sampling timeframe:

    10/2024 - 09/2025


    Confidence interval:

    90% to <95%


    Margin of error:

    +/-0.05

Causes

During the FY2026 Payment Integrity Information Act (PIIA) review, a statistically significant sample of 1,425 payments in the Military Retirement - Retired Pay program revealed an estimated improper plus unknown payment rate of 0.11% and an estimated $71.9M in improper and unknown payments. Improper and unknown payments were categorized into four primary root cause types: Monetary Loss to the Agency (MLA), Technically Improper Payments, Underpayments (UN), and Unknown Payments (UP).

Monetary Losses to the Agency (MLA) represented the highest volume and financial impact, totaling an estimated $63.1M ($63,091,078) across 91 sampled instances. The root causes for these overpayments include incorrect manual computations for credits, projected at approximately $35.7M, and SBP-related computation errors, projected at $13.8M. Furthermore, miscalculations of Gross Pay contributed an estimated $13.45M to the total losses, which was specifically driven by incorrect High-3 Average (HAVG) gross pay calculations (projected at $11.5M) and incorrect pay computation data points (projected at $1.9M).

Technically Improper Payments (SIP) accounted for $5.7M ($5,654,034) in projected errors. The specific scenario causing these statutory errors was incorrect account identification, specifically related to incorrect check addresses or account types. Additionally, Underpayments (UN) accounted for $3.1M ($3,122,724) in projected errors. These were caused by calculation scenarios similar to the monetary losses, primarily SBP-related miscalculations which projected roughly $1.5M of the underpayment total.

Finally, Unknown Payments (UP) totaled just over $69,000 ($69,237) in projected errors, primarily driven by missing or insufficient documentation to verify entitlements. Specific scenarios included SBP-related unknown payments (projected at $38,000) and unverified gross pay computation data points (projected at $31,000). Without this critical documentation, the agency could not definitively determine whether the payments were proper.

Overpayment root cause Overpayment amount
Amount of overpayments within the agency's control $63.1 M
Amount of overpayments outside the agency's control $0.0 M
Amount of overpayments that occurred because the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment does not exist $0.0 M
Amount of overpayments that occurred because of an inability to access the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment $0.0 M
Amount of overpayments that occurred because of a failure to access data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment $63.1 M

Underpayment root cause Underpayment amount
Amount of underpayments $3.1 M
The amount of underpayments that occurred because the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment does not exist $0.0 M
The amount of underpayments that occurred because of an inability to access the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment $0.0 M
The amount of underpayments that occurred because of a failure to access data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment $3.1 M

The amount of improper payments that were paid to the right recipient for the correct amount but were considered technically improper because of failure to follow statute or regulation $5.7 M

The amount that could either be proper or improper but the agency is unable to determine whether it was proper or improper as a result of insufficient or lack of documentation $0.07 M

Prevention

To address the root causes of improper and unknown payments, the Military Retirement - Retired Pay program is actively executing and expanding upon the milestones established in its FY2025 Corrective Action Plan (CAP). Because the FY2026 PIIA review tests payments made during FY2025, many of these robust corrective actions were implemented after the sampled payments were made. To directly address the root causes of Survivor Benefit Plan (SBP) errors, Gross Pay computation omissions, and HAVG calculation errors driving the majority of Monetary Losses (MLA) and Underpayments (UN), the agency implemented a Smart Wizard for the 2656 form in September 2025. This guides customers through accurate form completion to improve initial data entry. Furthermore, the agency implemented an AI Data Scrape of the 2656 form in November 2025 to automatically extract key information, minimizing manual input errors and streamlining processing.

To resolve HAVG calculation discrepancies stemming from account reconciliation errors, a System Change Request (SCR) was implemented in the 3rd Quarter of 2024 to catch discrepant data errors before they transfer to the Retired Casualty Pay System (RCPS). The full reduction impacts for new retirements established after June 2024 are expected to be verified by September 30, 2026. Additionally, to address incorrect VA Waiver withholdings driving further overpayments, a targeted SCR is scheduled for implementation by December 31, 2026. This will hold VA data in the Defense Retired/Annuitant Pay System (DRAS) until the member's shell account is built, eliminating manual lookups and ensuring timely waiver withholding.

To mitigate the remaining Unknown Payments (UP) and Technically Improper Payments caused by missing documentation (such as Orders) and incorrect addresses, R&A continues to emphasize compliance with federal documentation retention policies. The agency maintains a strict follow-up process and will proactively request hard copy orders or clarification from the Branches of Service (BoS) for incomplete submissions.

The planned and ongoing corrective actions in the agency's corrective action plan are directly proportional to the severity of the associated amounts and error rates of each root cause type identified in the current review. Monetary Losses (MLA) represented the highest financial severity at $63.1 million. This financial impact justifies the resource-intensive, multi-pronged approach of implementing the Smart Wizard and AI Data Scrape technologies to target $13.8 million in SBP errors and $13.45 million in Gross Pay miscalculations. Although these specific automation tools were deployed after the FY2025 payments being tested were made, they remain proportionally aligned to correct these ongoing high-dollar vulnerabilities. Similarly, targeted System Change Requests (SCRs) are being strategically deployed to systematically resolve VA Waiver and HAVG discrepancies before they result in future overpayments or contribute to the $3.1 million in identified Underpayments (UN). Unknown Payments (UP) accounted for a significantly lower financial risk of roughly $69,000 due to missing documentation. Proportionally, the agency is addressing this smaller monetary impact via a targeted follow-up process with the Branches of Service rather than initiating costly system overhauls. By aligning our most robust automated interventions with the highest dollar-value root causes, the level of ongoing corrective action remains strictly proportional to the financial risk.

To ensure that corrective actions are effectively implemented and prioritized within DFAS, proposed corrective action plans are reviewed and approved by the DFAS Mission Area Director responsible for oversight of the payment program, as well as the DFAS Enterprise Accounting & Audit Support Director. Once approved, these directors are briefed monthly on milestone completion and Improper and Unknown Payment rates to monitor the effectiveness of actions taken. The actions are strictly focused on the identified causes; for instance, the implementation of the Smart Wizard and AI Data Scrape directly targets inaccuracies stemming from the 2656 form, which is the key source of errors for SBP, Gross Pay, and HAVG calculations driving Monetary Losses. Furthermore, planned and executed System Change Requests (SCRs) address specific, known system flaws contributing to VA Waiver and data transfer errors.

The corrective actions are proven to be highly adequate and effective in addressing and preventing Improper Payments. This is strongly evidenced by the massive reduction in the projected Improper Payment estimate, which dropped from the $651 million projected in the FY2025 CAP down to $71.9 million (0.11%) in FY2026 as previously established systemic controls (like the Q3 2024 SCR) took effect. However, because the FY2026 PIIA review evaluates payments made in FY2025, the full impact of the massive FY2025 CAP milestones (such as the September 2025 Smart Wizard deployment) will not be fully realized until the FY2027 review cycle. Management will utilize other available improper payment data to monitor current performance along with FY2027 PIIA Payment Review results to evidence the continued effective implementation and further reduction of errors.

Payment type Mitigation strategies taken Mitigation strategies planned
Overpayments Change Process, Training Change Process, Cross Enterprise Sharing, Training
Underpayments Change Process, Training Change Process, Cross Enterprise Sharing, Training
Technically improper payments Change Process, Training Change Process, Cross Enterprise Sharing, Training
Unknown payments Training, Change Process Training, Change Process, Cross Enterprise Sharing

Eligibility element/information needed Description of the eligbility element/information
Marital Status A person's state of being single, married, separated, divorced, or widowed
Military Status The condition of being, or having been in the uniformed services
Residency Status of recipient's living location or arrangement

Additional information

Reduction target

0.1 %

The Military Retirement - Retired Pay program possesses the necessary internal controls, reinforced by upstream policy coordination with OUSW(C), to effectively reduce improper and unknown payments to the proposed levels. Furthermore, the agency has the requisite human capital to execute these improvements through targeted refresher training and specialized computational workshops. Finally, existing information systems and infrastructure are fully adequate to process these payments accurately, ensuring that any further expenditures to engineer new, complex systemic controls would likely cost more to implement than they would ultimately save.

The Military Retirement - Retired Pay program possesses the necessary internal controls, reinforced by upstream policy coordination with OUSW(C), to effectively reduce improper and unknown payments to the proposed levels. Furthermore, the agency has the requisite human capital to execute these improvements through targeted refresher training and specialized computational workshops. Finally, existing information systems and infrastructure are adequate to process these payments accurately, avoiding the need for costly system logic overhauls. Any further expenditure to engineer new, more complex systemic controls would likely cost more to implement and maintain than the amount they would ultimately save in recovered or prevented improper payments.

The Military Retirement – Retired Pay program maintains the operational infrastructure, robust internal controls, and data validation capabilities necessary to systematically reduce improper payments and sustain long-term payment integrity. Current budgetary allocations fully support all planned mitigation strategies, internal review protocols, and targeted workforce training initiatives required to minimize disbursement errors. Because existing operating resources remain sufficient to uphold payment accuracy and compliance standards, the agency did not request supplemental funding for payment integrity in the most recent budget submission.

The Department of War (DoW) is actively integrating artificial intelligence (AI) and automation into its financial management (FM) practices to achieve an unmodified audit opinion. Disparate FM systems will be unified in a single, AI-powered source of truth. It will utilize AI agents to enable real-time monitoring, automated system-to-system reconciliations, and an auditable trail. Through this new capability and additional software, the DoW will address pervasive issues for improper pay through rule-based detection, proactive controls, and end to end capabilities.

Accountability for reducing improper payments within the Military Retirement - Retired Pay program is a top priority for agency leadership. The Mission Area Director is directly responsible for meeting our improper payment reduction targets. Their annual performance criteria include specific, measurable metrics tied directly to establishing internal controls, reducing payment errors, and the timely execution of corrective action plans. Furthermore, their performance appraisals evaluate their success in detecting overpayments and recovering those overpayments promptly. Progress is monitored actively through monthly executive steering committee meetings, where key performance indicators and root cause trends are heavily analyzed. Repeated failure to meet these targets or maintain adequate controls will result in negative performance evaluations and potential reassignment, ensuring strict adherence to our financial goals.

Beginning in FY 2026, all agencies must adopt the new Senior Executive Service (SES) performance plans established by the U.S. Office of Personnel Management pursuant to the January 20, 2025, Presidential Memorandum, Restoring Accountability for Career Senior Executives. The highest-weighted element, “Faithful Administration of the Law and the President’s Policies,” reinforces executive accountability for achieving Department of War (DoW) priorities.

Accordingly, SES members responsible for Financial Improvement and Audit Remediation (FIAR) outcomes will include specific, measurable performance requirements aligned with annual financial statement audit priorities. SES members with direct FIAR responsibilities will ensure compliance with applicable policies, maintain effective internal controls and supporting documentation, respond timely to auditor requests, remediate priority material weaknesses, and execute audit roadmaps and corrective action plans supporting an unmodified audit opinion. SES members with indirect responsibilities will implement measurable corrective actions, maintain documentation supporting financial transactions, and ensure personnel are trained and accountable.
These requirements strengthen DoW accountability for audit readiness, payment integrity, efficient operations, and compliance with the Payment Integrity Information Act (PIIA).

The DoW Payment Integrity Senior Accountable Officials Steering Committee provides senior-level oversight of these efforts. Chaired by the Office of the Under Secretary of War (Comptroller)/Deputy Chief Financial Officer and co-chaired by the Director, Defense Finance and Accounting Service, the Committee monitors improper payment testing, root-cause analysis, recovery activities, audit findings, risk assessments, and corrective actions required under Appendix C of OMB Circular A-123.

$8.8 M