Employment & Training Administration - Federal State Unemployment Insurance
High-priority program
Program level Payment Integrity results
Sponsoring agency: Department of Labor
The UI programs provide temporary, partial wage replacement to eligible workers. The top three root causes for OPs in the UC programs are BYE, Work Search, and Separation Issue improper payments (IPs). Barriers to prevention include (1) increasingly sophisticated/evolving fraud schemes, including identity fraud; (2) 53 states and territories administering the program in accordance with state law and across different IT systems; and (3) statutory requirements to provide due process, which includes balancing legal requirements with paying benefits quickly.
View on Federal Program InventoryPROGRAM METRICS
$40,021 M
in FY 2026 outlays, with a
85.2%
payment accuracy rate
-
Improper payment estimates over time
View as:
Chart toggle amounts:Proper paymentsOverpaymentUnderpaymentTechnically improperUnknown
Payment Integrity results
-
FY 2026 improper payment estimates
Chart legend and breakdown
Payment accuracy rate
Improper payment rate
Unknown payment rate
Sampling & estimation methodology details
Sampling timeframe:
07/2025 - 06/2026
Confidence interval:
95% to <100%
Margin of error:
+/-0.8
Causes
Root Cause – Work Search. Work Search IPs occur when UI claimants fail to properly document or report their work search efforts or fail to comply with state work search requirements. Federal law requires that, as a condition of eligibility, all states require UI claimants to make an active search for work. However, the specific work search requirements vary greatly across state laws and states do not uniformly require UI claimants to report these activities prior to releasing payment. Most Work Search overpayments do not typically occur due to fraudulent activity. Many Work Search IPs result from mistakes made by claimants, either because the claimant misunderstood the state’s work search requirements or because the claimant did not keep good records documenting their work search efforts. Further, if a claimant does provide documentation of their work search efforts, states struggle to verify work search attempts with employers. Most employers do not maintain detailed records of all job inquiries and/or applications and there are a lack of incentives for employers to do so.
Root Cause – BYE. BYE IPs often occur when a UI claimant intentionally or unintentionally fails to report earnings or underreports their earnings to receive benefits – when intentionally withheld, state law may find it to be fraudulent. BYE IPs may also result from a UI claimant’s misunderstanding regarding how to report their earnings. For example, a UI claimant may report only their net wages instead of their gross wages, as required. Another common cause of BYE IPs occurs when a UI claimant waits to report their earnings from employment until they are paid by the employer instead of reporting their earnings when they are earned.
Root Cause – Separations. Separation IPs occur when UI claimants receive benefits and are later determined to be ineligible due to a disqualifying separation from previous employment. Employer participation is critical for maintaining program integrity and states must request information from employers on the reason for the claimant’s separation from employment. However, if states are unable to get timely and accurate information from employers, states are legally required to make a determination using the best available information (also known as the “payment when due” requirement discussed in more detail below). Failure of employers or their third-party administrators to provide timely and adequate information on the reason for an individual’s separation from employment presents a major challenge to addressing Separation IPs. Additionally, individuals may misrepresent or misunderstand their separation reason at the time of filing – either intentionally (which may result in a finding of fraud under state UI law) or unintentionally (e.g., when communication at the time of separation between the worker and their employer was unclear).
Unknown Payments. Unknown payments occur when the Federal deadlines for IP reporting come earlier than BAM deadlines for case completion. If BAM does not have time to complete all cases prior to Federal IP reporting, outstanding cases become unknown IPs. Unknown IPs are also caused by insufficient and/or untrained state BAM staff which can lead to delays in completing cases timely.
UI as a Federal-State Partnership. The UI program is a federal-state partnership based on Federal law and administered through individual state laws by 53 different workforce agencies (SWAs), which are the 50 states, the District of Columbia, the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands. See 26 U.S.C. § 3306(j)(1). States vary in their organizational structures within state government and infrastructure, such as IT systems, level of automation, and staffing capacity. While all states must meet certain federal requirements, state laws vary in methods and strategies for prevention, detection, and recovery of IPs. Additionally, no two states' laws, regulations, and policies specifying UI eligibility conditions are identical, and differences in these conditions influence the potential for error and IPs.
State agencies operate the UI program and administer benefit payments. Thus, overpayments originate from state UI agency program administration issues. DOL’s oversight role requires holding states accountable and if DOL determines a state is out of conformity and/or substantial compliance with Federal law, it can withhold certification of a state's law after notice and hearing. This results in the loss of federal unemployment tax credits for employers in the state and/or the state's ability to receive federal administrative grants to operate the program. DOL does not have enforcement authority to compel such efforts at a more intermediate level, such as by withholding a portion of funding to address any issues. Additionally, Federal law does not provide DOL with the authority to prescribe, beyond a certain level, how states administer the program.
“Payment When Due” Provision. Section 303(a)(1) of the Social Security Act requires UI payments to be made when due, meaning once a person is determined initially eligible, states are prohibited from suspending payments beyond a certain time period if a new eligibility issue arises and while it is investigated – until an official determination on the new eligibility issue has been made that payments are no longer due. Put another way, after an individual is determined to be eligible, states must continue paying benefits until due process occurs (notice and an opportunity for a hearing is provided before benefit payments are stopped) for the newly-discovered issue. This means that some payments may later be determined improper as a result of obtaining new information. Moreover, unlike many other benefit programs, eligibility for UI benefits is determined on a weekly basis and this frequency creates more opportunities for errors.
For many IPs in the UI program, a state UI agency may identify an issue but fail to properly or timely follow its procedures for due process and resolution. Alternatively, the issue could have been the result of a third-party error/incorrect information. IPs may also occur in instances where the state agency was resolving the error or had detected the error as a result of a crossmatch (e.g., National Directory of New Hires or wage records) and an issue was detected after the payment was made because the data was not available in the crossmatch data source at the time the payment was due by law.
| Overpayment root cause | Overpayment amount |
|---|---|
| Amount of overpayments within the agency's control | $971.35 M |
| Amount of overpayments outside the agency's control | $3,813.17 M |
| Amount of overpayments that occurred because the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment does not exist | $0.0 M |
| Amount of overpayments that occurred because of an inability to access the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment | $3,976.7 M |
| Amount of overpayments that occurred because of a failure to access data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment | $807.82 M |
| Underpayment root cause | Underpayment amount |
|---|---|
| Amount of underpayments | $176.49 M |
| The amount of underpayments that occurred because the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment does not exist | $0.0 M |
| The amount of underpayments that occurred because of an inability to access the data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment | $140.92 M |
| The amount of underpayments that occurred because of a failure to access data/information needed to validate payment accuracy prior to making a payment | $35.58 M |
| The amount of improper payments that were paid to the right recipient for the correct amount but were considered technically improper because of failure to follow statute or regulation | $0.0 M |
| The amount that could either be proper or improper but the agency is unable to determine whether it was proper or improper as a result of insufficient or lack of documentation | $956.95 M |
Prevention
In FY 2026, DOL took aggressive action to hold states accountable for combatting fraud, addressing high IP rates, and improving UI program performance. In February, ETA sent individual notices to each state regarding specific performance measures, including the IP rate, and the resulting level of engagement they could expect from ETA as a result of this performance. In March, ETA convened state and federal leaders from all 53 state workforce agencies to discuss performance, integrity initiatives, policy issues, and reemployment strategies. Between March and September, ETA deployed UI Strike Teams to the worst-performing states, resulting in 22 onsite engagements and one additional engagement to assess to what extent fraud was impacting the state’s UI program. In June, ETA launched public State Performance Scorecards (https://oui.doleta.gov/unemploy/performance/StatePerfScorecard.html), tracking metrics like IP and fraud rates and benefit timeliness measures. In July, ETA issued model national UI standards for states to adopt to improve UI integrity, following a letter from the Secretary to state governors demanding action on fraud and performance. Results from the UI Strike Team engagements and ETA’s model national UI standards are being incorporated into state FY 2027 State Quality Service Plans (SQSP) (see UIPL No. 14-26).
ETA also leveraged funding to support integrity goals. The Reemployment Services and Eligibility Assessment (RESEA) program is aimed at improving employment outcomes and reducing fraud. In March 2026, ETA awarded over $38 million in grants to 46 states that met or exceeded their RESEA duration and reemployment outcome targets for FY 2025. In July 2026, ETA announced the latest Operating Guidance (see UIPL No. 13-26) and is providing states with over $415.6 million in grants to continue operation of their RESEA programs.
ETA deepened collaboration with the DOL OIG to safeguard taxpayer dollars and address UI fraud and performance issues. The partnership included regular meetings on emerging fraud trends, coordination with states, financial institutions, and unclaimed property agencies to recover unspent pandemic-era UI funds on prepaid debit cards, and joint engagement through UI Strike Team visits to strengthen DOL OIG and state relationships. DOL also published a final rule requiring states to share confidential UI information with federal officials, including DOL-OIG ensuring proper oversight and accountability for the UI program.
Finally, ETA advanced technology data programs and ID verification infrastructure. It deployed Unemployment.gov as an informational website in January and is set to launch an initial pilot in early FY 2027, providing a national front door for benefit applications with built-in fraud checks. It also upgraded ID verification by moving Login.gov to a higher assurance level and integrating USPS in-person proofing, having verified over 532,000 IDs and proofed over 377,000 others since February 2025. Additionally, the Integrity Data Hub (IDH) a multi-state fraud-detection data system, expanded access to Treasury's Do Not Pay (DNP) database and enhanced tools for identifying employer tax fraud schemes.
ETA's UI Integrity Strategic Plan ties each antifraud and IP reduction strategy to risks identified in the UI Fraud Risk Profile. ETA is coordinating across multiple stakeholders, including through the Vice President’s Task Force to Eliminate Fraud (Fraud Task Force), which includes strong representation from DOL’s Secretary and Inspector General. In June 2026, DOL issued a letter to the governors of all 53 states and territories, announcing its intent to crack down on UI fraud and mismanagement, using enforcement tools like withholding administrative funds. In July 2026, ETA followed up with letters to states, outlining the model national UI standards and expectations that states describe how they are addressing the model standards as part of their strategic planning for SQSP. ETA issued UIPL No. 14-26 in September 2026 to describe requirements for states’ FY 2027 SQSP, which included ETA’s National Priorities for the UI program and further amplified the model national UI standards. States are also required to submit an Integrity Action Plan (IAP) detailing their antifraud efforts.
UI fraud falls into two categories: eligibility fraud (false information to obtain benefits, like not reporting work) and ID fraud (using stolen or fake identities, including account takeovers and fictitious employer schemes). While fraud is a contributing factor to IPs, most IPs are not because of fraud. Eligibility-related non-fraud issues have and continue to be the primary drivers of UI IPs, with the top three leading root causes for 2026 being Work Search, BYE, and Separation issue errors. These eligibility related IPs are caused by claimant misunderstanding, employer response delays, and/or state administrative mistakes, and states are addressing these errors through plain-language communication and behavioral insights (BI) techniques like honesty prompts and nudges.
DOL also supports states through several other strategic investments, including, but not limited to:
• State Information Data Exchange System (SIDES): Streamlines employer information requests leading to more timely and accurate benefit determinations.
• The UI Integrity Center: Provides access to the Integrity Data Hub (IDH) for crossmatching and data analytics, technical assistance, consultative services, training, and BI support to states to improve UI program integrity.
• UI Information Technology Support Center (ITSC): Offers products and services to support states with IT modernization in UI programs.
• UI Interstate Connection Network (ICON): Supports the exchange of information for states to process interstate benefits claims and collect overpayments.
Together, these investments form a comprehensive, risk-prioritized approach to reducing UI fraud and IPs.
Since the UI program is primarily funded by employers through state and Federal tax liability and administered through a Federal-state partnership, both DOL and state UI agencies have a vested interest in ensuring UI program integrity and are jointly responsible for managing the process of assessing and mitigating fraud risks to the UI program, reducing IPs, and prioritizing payment integrity activities. ETA provides funding, monitors state performance, issues guidance, and offers training and resources, but states alone determine eligibility and are responsible for directly preventing, detecting, and recovering IPs. ETA requires states to report, in their IAP submission, their state-specific UI antifraud strategy, which includes state actions to evaluate UI fraud risks and implement and maintain sufficient controls to effectively prevent fraud and reduce IPs. States are also required to report on how they are addressing the model national UI standards, efforts to target the root cause of IPs, and actions taken to recover overpayments.
Reducing the UI IP rate below 10 percent remains a DOL priority. While ETA's FY 2026 antifraud and IP reduction strategies have proven adequate, as identified by a continued year-over-year decline in the IP rate since 2021, the rate remains above the 10% threshold. ETA remains committed to further risk assessment and strategy implementation to bring the program into compliance with PIIA.
| Payment type | Mitigation strategies taken | Mitigation strategies planned |
|---|---|---|
| Overpayments | Audit, Automation, Behavioral/Psych Influence, Change Process, Cross Enterprise Sharing, Predictive Analytics, Statutory Change, Training | Audit, Automation, Behavioral/Psych Influence, Change Process, Cross Enterprise Sharing, Predictive Analytics, Statutory Change, Training |
| Underpayments | Audit, Automation, Behavioral/Psych Influence, Change Process, Cross Enterprise Sharing, Predictive Analytics, Statutory Change, Training | Audit, Automation, Behavioral/Psych Influence, Change Process, Cross Enterprise Sharing, Predictive Analytics, Statutory Change, Training |
| Unknown payments | Training | Automation, Training, Change Process |
| Eligibility element/information needed | Description of the eligbility element/information |
|---|---|
| Citizenship | Recognized as a United States citizen through birth or naturalization, or as a lawfully present non-citizen in the United States |
| Dependency | Describes who the recipient/beneficiary relies on as a primary source of support |
| Employment | The employment status of the recipient/beneficiary |
| Identity | Able to establish that someone is uniquely who they claim to be |
| Receiving Benefits from Other Sources | Beneficiary or recipient is receiving benefits from an additional source |
Additional information
Reduction target
9.9 %IPs and unknown payments are driven by the processes and performance of 53 different SWAs. Factors that prevent states from reducing IPs include variation in state organizational structures and infrastructure such as outdated IT systems, loss of experienced staff and constraints in onboarding new staff, as well as complex and/or stringent state-specific UI laws for eligibility requirements such as work search activities. Additionally, states report that the reduction and/or flat funding of Federal administrative grants to states is also a factor that inhibits state progress towards reducing the improper payment rate.
DOL is constrained in its ability to hold states accountable for intermediary progress. Specifically, if DOL determines a state is out of conformity and/or substantial compliance with federal law, it can withhold certification of a state's law after notice and hearing. This results in the loss of Federal unemployment tax credits for employers in the state and/or the state's ability to receive administrative grants to operate the program. Additionally, Federal law does not provide DOL with the authority to prescribe beyond a certain level how states administer the program.
The FY 2027 President’s Budget request included $25,000,000 to fund identity verification activities to help states combat identity fraud in the UI system. The FY 2028 President’s Budget has not yet been released. ETA is working with OMB to assess whether there are specific proposals to include in the forthcoming FY 2028 President's Budget.
Through the SQSP process, states are required to submit IAPs to identify state-specific root causes of IPs and strategies to address each root cause. Additionally, states with IP rates at or above 10 percent are required to develop corrective action plans (CAPs) aimed at reducing their IP rate. States are also required to report allegations which the state reasonably believes constitutes UI fraud, waste, abuse, mismanagement, or misconduct to the DOL OIG (see UIPL No. 04-17, Change 1). ETA’s oversight process includes UI Strike Team engagements with states reporting a high IP rate or chronic poor performance; regular reviews of CAP milestones and updates; peer reviews for BAM, Appeals, and Benefits Timeliness and Quality; and monitoring and technical assistance to states on an ongoing basis. In FY 2026, ETA conducted a national BAM peer review with all states, providing intensive training in BAM coding, alongside UI Strike Team observations aimed at improving program performance.
Further, ETA’s Agency Management Plan (AMP) outlines the following “Strategic Goal” for UI program integrity:
• Reducing the Improper Payment Rate. ETA will hold states accountable by 1) prioritizing its resources toward more direct oversight of the UI program; 2) addressing root cause issues and providing system supports and tools to states whose performance has fallen short of acceptable levels; and 3) coordinating with the DOL OIG to strengthen UI fraud prevention and detection across the UI program, including direct engagement with states to address UI fraud. These efforts will support reduction of the Improper Payment Rate.
ETA’s AMP also outlines the following “Strategic Goal” for the timely payment of UI benefits:
• Leveraging Strategic DOL Investments: ETA will support the timeliness of UI benefit payments by encouraging states to fully leverage the IDH and SIDES. These systems help ensure timely and accurate responses from employers and support states in detecting potential fraud and IPs by facilitating information collection from relevant stakeholders, enabling crossmatching with key data sources, and supporting data analytics to help states prioritize investigations. These efforts will support improvements in timely payment of benefits, appeals promptness, and strengthened integrity in the UI system.
ETA executive leadership and Office of Unemployment Insurance managers are held accountable, through annual performance appraisals, for advancing the AMP Strategic Goals.