Railroad Retirement Board

The RRB has benefit paying and non-benefit paying programs. The benefit paying programs consist of railroad retirement and survivor benefit (RRA) payments and railroad unemployment and sickness insurance benefit (RUIA) payments. Non-benefit paying programs include vendor payments and employee payments. The RRB’s benefit paying and non-benefit paying programs have consistently fallen below the statutory thresholds for “significant improper payments” as defined by the PIIA. As a result, these programs operate under Phase 1 guidance under OMB Circular A-123, Appendix C (M-21-19), which places them in a three-year risk assessment cycle unless there are major changes to the program that would require an earlier assessment.

The RRB’s OIG found the agency compliant with the PIIA in their most recent audit, “The Railroad Retirement Board Complied with the Payment Integrity Information Act for Fiscal Year 2024 (25-05).” One of the recommendations focused on consolidating the payment integrity portions of the separate assessable units within the Bureau of Fiscal Operations (BFO) and the Office of Programs (OP), into one Payment Integrity Assessable Unit (AU) for the entire agency. The RRB concurred with this recommendation and created a new Payment Integrity AU in fiscal year 2026. This new AU will follow the Enterprise Risk Management model, evaluate payment integrity risks and controls across BFO and OP, and will undergo full testing of control techniques in fiscal year 2027. The Payment Integrity AU has officials from both BFO and OP who are responsible for certifying each organization’s payment integrity controls. The RRB is confident that this new AU will maintain and strengthen payment integrity for the agency.

The RRA program underwent its regularly scheduled risk assessment in FY 2026. The assessment reflected that the program continues to report estimates under the statutory thresholds of “significant improper payments” and should remain under Phase 1 guidelines. As a result, the next scheduled risk assessment for the RRA program will be in fiscal year 2029. In the interim, the program will continue to undergo monitoring which includes quality assurance and validation reviews. The RRA program also features monitoring and program integrity activities including representative payee monitoring, parental custody monitoring, disabled ineligible persons included (IPI) monitoring, super-aged monitoring, and the centenarian program.

In regard to an RUIA risk assessment, the program is not scheduled for its next regular assessment until FY 2028. However, the RRB considered whether passage of the Railroad Employee Equity and Fairness (REEF) Act, which permanently ended the 5.7% sequestration cut to RUIA and sickness benefits, constituted a major change to the RUIA program requiring an off-cycle assessment. OMB Circular A-123, Appendix C, indicates agencies have discretion to determine whether or not to proceed with such an assessment and should only do so if a particular factor (i.e. REEF) would be significant enough to “cause the program to become likely to make IPs and UPs that would collectively be above the statutory threshold.” Because agency systems were reprogrammed to prevent sequestration cuts, and REEF required retroactive payments for known amounts resulting from claims previously paid, REEF would not cause the program to become likely to make future IPs and UPs. Therefore, the agency did not complete an off-cycle assessment in FY 2026.

Non-benefits-paying programs’ also conducted risk assessments in FY 2026 and results concluded that both vendor payments and employee payments continue to report under the statutory thresholds of $100 million or 10 million and 1.5% of each program’s outlays and should continue to report under Phase 1 guidelines. As a result, the vendor payments and employee payments programs are scheduled to conduct risk assessments in fiscal year 2029. Quality Assurance Reports (QARs) are performed by the Management Controls and Compliance Section and conducted annually during on-cycle and off-cycle years for Vendor and Employee Payment programs. QARs are used to validate the effectiveness and compliance of each program’s internal processes and procedures. The new Payment Integrity AU will further strengthen payment integrity efforts for the vendor payment and employee payment programs.

Show full executive summary

Recovery information

View as:

Chart toggle amounts:
Overpayment amount identified for recapture
Overpayment amount recovered

Recovery of overpayments

Please note: Overpayment amounts recovered are reported in the year they were recovered, not the year they were identified. Therefore it is possible in some years to have a recovery rate greater than 100%.

Overpayment amount identified through recovery activities $95.8 M
Overpayment amount recovered through recovery activities $81.8 M
Recovery activities recovery rate 85.39 %

Why recovery audits are not cost effective in certain programs

The agency remains diligent in its efforts to recover overpayments and prevent improper payments. Quality Assurance Reports (QARs) targeting vendor and employee payment programs are conducted annually during on-cycle and off-cycle years. These reviews form a robust monitoring framework that consistently yields a zero percent error rate. The most recent results for Fiscal Year 2025 showed no evidence of improper payments.

Additionally, the agency performs a bi-weekly payroll review that includes comparing an HR Links report—showing hours certified by supervisors—with a General Services Administration (GSA) report identifying payroll amounts for the same period. The totals from these two reports are reconciled. To date, this process has revealed no indication of improper payroll payments.

Given the effectiveness of current internal controls, implementing a formal payment recapture audit program or alternative method for vendor and employee payments would not be cost-effective. Overall, the agency's existing activities constitute a comprehensive and effective alternative to a formal recapture audit program.

Intentional monetary loss improper payments are more commonly referred to as financial fraud and are overpayments that occur on purpose. This agency reported $0.59M of confirmed fraud in this reporting cycle.

Supplemental Information

The agency has determined that our current business processes, data sources, and the Do Not Pay Initiative are effective in detecting and preventing benefit overpayments. As a benefits paying agency, the RRB receives pre-payment information regarding benefit entitlement at other agencies and wage information. We have ongoing data sources established and in use for this information, which include benefit entitlement and wage data from SSA, employers, and our application process. We also receive post-payment wage information through established sources such as the State Wage Match program. In addition, we receive death data directly from SSA and CMS, which provides detailed and timely death information. Collectively, these data exchanges enable the RRB to verify eligibility prior to payment and to identify post-payment changes that may affect benefit amounts. When combined with internal business rules and review procedures, these data sources form a comprehensive framework for minimizing
improper payments and maintaining payment accuracy. The RRB uses Do Not Pay Payment Verification services daily and monthly as a pre-payment control to screen benefit payments against multiple data sources, including the Death Master File (DMF). Current results indicate that Do Not Pay provides an additional layer of review and supports existing controls. Match rates to date remain below one percent of total payments; in FY 2026 to date, Do Not Pay screened 4.49 million RRB payments totaling $12.13 billion and matched 4.87 thousand in payments (totaling $12.71 million) via DMF data.

The Working System has reduced/prevented improper payments:

The Working System strives to maintain accurate data. However, the past year, RRB has identified incorrect information in the Working System Daily.

RRB was found compliant during the most recent PIIA compliance review.

Show full list of compliant programs Expand

Compliant programs:

  • Employee Payments – Railroad Retirement Board
  • Railroad Retirement Act
  • Railroad Unemployment Insurance Act
  • Vendor Payments – Railroad Retirement Board

Program name When was the last improper payment risk assessment conducted? Likely to be susceptible to significant improper payments? Substantial changes made to the assessment methodology used for the reporting cycle
Employee Payments – Railroad Retirement Board 2026 No No
Railroad Retirement Act 2026 No No
Railroad Unemployment Insurance Act 2025 No No
Vendor Payments – Railroad Retirement Board 2026 No No